Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   How good are Creedence Clearwater Revival? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=17261)

gmku 10.29.2007 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Savage Clone
I can't do Creedence.
Attempts were made, but it didn't take.


Same here. Even when I was kid, which was back in their day, they seemed like my parents' band.

I think kids today are becoming like my parents, and I am becoming, to kids today, like a rebellious teenager.

Rob Instigator 10.30.2007 07:47 AM

Mudhoney was Creedence with heroin.

the guitar

Everyneurotic 10.30.2007 10:12 AM

mudhoney was crap who had a lot of luck.

Bicorn Halfelven 10.30.2007 11:41 PM

Harsh, but for the most part, i have to agree.

gmku 10.30.2007 11:45 PM

Credence < Mudhoney < < < Nirvana

5Against1 10.31.2007 12:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmku
Credence < Mudhoney < < < Nirvana

Pixies < Meat Puppets < Vasilines <<< Nirvana

shentov 10.31.2007 01:19 AM

in their early days mudhoney probably copped heroin from creedence fans. then kurt cobain went all pop and shared his man.
$ 400 a day - beat that!

alyasa 10.31.2007 01:25 AM

Creedence < Pixies < Meat Puppets < (The) Melvins <<<< Nirvana

therealglenstyler 10.31.2007 05:13 AM

ugh, id rather tour manage billy corgan than take in a single lick of this hippy trash.

Rob Instigator 10.31.2007 08:36 AM

meat pupets suck major ass. Oh my god. fucking sped up country music. fucking SHIT. I hated them when they were first around and I hateed hearing their boring boring country rock opening up for the sonic youth in austin earlier this month.

Mudhoney rule all! mudhoney is a mix of stooges and creedence, an dthat is EXCELLENT to my ears

Bicorn Halfelven 10.31.2007 11:14 AM

There's a boot of Nirvana doing a cover of CCR's "Bad Moon Rising" out there.

I can post if anybody's interested.

atari 2600 10.31.2007 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bicorn Halfelven
There's a boot of Nirvana doing a cover of CCR's "Bad Moon Rising" out there.

I can post if anybody's interested.


I'm not so keen on their cover of CCR's "Bad Moon Rising."

Love their Meat Puppets covers and how they do Mudhoney's "The Money Will Roll Right In."

Their cover of The Cars' "My Best Friend's Girl" is downright embarrassing.

more
http://rateyourmusic.com/list/mutant...these_artists/

alyasa 10.31.2007 12:18 PM

Meat Puppets? I think they're ok... Violent Femmes is another 'Americana' band I like... Very outre...

Torn Curtain 11.01.2007 04:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by therealglenstyler
ugh, id rather tour manage billy corgan than take in a single lick of this hippy trash.


CCR hippy trash ? Are you serious ?

jetengine 11.01.2007 08:34 AM

'Bootleg' and 'Born On the Bayou' were great tracks. 'Have You Ever Seen the Rain' was probably their best out-and-out commercial single.

gmku 11.01.2007 11:34 AM

I like the Pixies. I don't care what any of you Pixies-haters say.

Rob Instigator 11.01.2007 11:59 AM

Pixies are very good stuff.
they rock. if ya wanna ROCK you oculd do much much worse.

Everyneurotic 11.01.2007 12:19 PM

mudhoney were like the dead boys mixed with the dead boys, it's just another garage band trying to be the yardbirds, only in the 80's. BUT they were in SEATTLE, and they released shit in SUB POP and they influenced KURT COBANG so they must be godheads!!!

i was a bit harsh, since i enjoy many of their songs but, they are not that special. rather listen to the mummies than mudhoney.

pixies are also overrated but they wrote and arranged a ton of amazing songs.

jetengine 11.01.2007 10:13 PM

Not sure why we're talking about The Pixies here all of a sudden, but I just wanted to admit that I've never understood all the hooplah over The Pixies--or Frank Black's solo career. As far as I'm concerned, they were just another one of those '80s/early '90s 'alternative' bands whose best tracks were the handful of commercial tracks--i.e., the singles--that could (supposedly) compete with or outshine the hits of the most respectable bestselling bands (The Cure, U2, INXS, The Smiths, REM, etc.). Take their 'classic' Doolittle album for example: 'Monkey Gone to Heaven', 'Here Comes Your Man' and maybe 'Wave of Mutilation' carry the entire record--the rest of the tracks you probably listened to once or twice and haven't returned to since. It's the same thing with Black's second solo record: it's just 'Headache' and 'Abstract Plain'--the two singles--and the rest is just immemorable third-rate filler.

Come to think of it, The Breeders were probably the best thing to ever come out of The Pixies...

Rob Instigator 11.02.2007 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jetengine
Not sure why we're talking about The Pixies here all of a sudden, but I just wanted to admit that I've never understood all the hooplah over The Pixies--or Frank Black's solo career. As far as I'm concerned, they were just another one of those '80s/early '90s 'alternative' bands whose best tracks were the handful of commercial tracks--i.e., the singles--that could (supposedly) compete with or outshine the hits of the most respectable bestselling bands (The Cure, U2, INXS, The Smiths, REM, etc.). Take their 'classic' Doolittle album for example: 'Monkey Gone to Heaven', 'Here Comes Your Man' and maybe 'Wave of Mutilation' carry the entire record--the rest of the tracks you probably listened to once or twice and haven't returned to since. It's the same thing with Black's second solo record: it's just 'Headache' and 'Abstract Plain'--the two singles--and the rest is just immemorable third-rate filler.

Come to think of it, The Breeders were probably the best thing to ever come out of The Pixies...


This is horrible revisionist thinking. the pixies were fucking amazing and are still amazing and theuir first EP's and albums rock harder than anything "indie" these days. The breeders fucking suck shit compared to the pixies. DEBASER alone trumps anything the breeders ever put out.


this is what happens when a band is ripped off by EVERYONE to such an extent that the rip-offs garner more publcity and more airplay and people go back to hear the original and find it boring.
that's YOUR fault, not the pixies.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:55 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth