Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Is Trump really a serious contender for the Republican nomination? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=113183)

!@#$%! 05.24.2020 09:08 PM

someone call the toymaker cuz this doll is broken

 

GeneticKiss 05.24.2020 11:58 PM

I've got alot to say, but since the forum limits the number of characters per post, I've got to break it in half...


Trump is the EPITOME of male white corporate oppression. How could anyone listen to a band like Sonic Youth and be of the Trumpist mindset?

The absence of the band this community came together for has led to a massive drop in quality posters. When I was originally here during the Bush Jr. era, we chewed up right-wingers and spit 'em out. Now the alt-right has infected here as well?!

Trump has exactly 2 talents: 1) making himself look better than he is and 2) leaving others to clean up his mess when things inevitably fall apart. He's only rich because of his inherited wealth from his father, he's only famous because his exploits make for good tabloid fodder, and he's only President because we still have an archaic system that somehow equates empty land with people...

GeneticKiss 05.24.2020 11:59 PM

...3 MILLION people's votes were basically flushed down the toilet, simply because they were in the "wrong" state. The only thing he's MAYBE good for is ironic comedy.

Anyone who supports Trump is either a genuine fool or someone so desperate for change and/or brainwashed by right-wing media into thinking the Republican party aren't keeping them under their thumb by paying lip service to "hardworking Christian family values" while robbing them blind to ensure the rich stay firmly in power, getting richer while making the poor even poorer.

I thought you had to have a head on your shoulders or at least a forward-thinking mindset to appreciate SY's music. Guess I was wrong.

The Soup Nazi 05.25.2020 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneticKiss
I thought you had to have a head on your shoulders or at least a forward-thinking mindset to appreciate SY's music. Guess I was wrong.


It happens with so much music: The Smiths, Springsteen... I'm sure some slave owners dug the songs of pain their "properties" were singing. Homophobes dancing to Cole Porter. Racists rockin' to electric Chicago blues. The disconnection is and has been staggering.

h8kurdt 05.25.2020 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Soup Nazi
It happens with so much music: The Smiths, Springsteen... I'm sure some slave owners dug the songs of pain their "properties" were singing. Homophobes dancing to Cole Porter. Racists rockin' to electric Chicago blues. The disconnection is and has been staggering.


Oh man, don't get me started on Bruce Springsteen fans. It's the same with Neil Young fans. You ever see that clip where he was playing with CSN and they did a song called flip flop live which was a song about how useless W. Bush is (oh those glory days). So many fans were storming out of the gig shouting at the cameras how they'll never listen to Neil Young's music ever again. I mean, you guys have followed his career pretty closely, right? Why would him coming out as being against Bush be a surprise?

But yeah, back to the point of not understanding how you can be totally on the opposite end of what sonic youth have always preached and be ok with it. I can't ever imagine wanting to listen to Nazi punk.

Screaming Skull 05.26.2020 10:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneticKiss
Trump is the EPITOME of male white corporate oppression. How could anyone listen to a band like Sonic Youth and be of the Trumpist mindset?

The absence of the band this community came together for has led to a massive drop in quality posters. When I was originally here during the Bush Jr. era, we chewed up right-wingers and spit 'em out. Now the alt-right has infected here as well?!


Pure, unadulterated ignorance on full display here, folks. While Sonic Youth do have some political songs, they are far from being a political band. But please, GeneticKiss, continue to tell me what I'm allowed to like/dislike. I used to be all for diversity and inclusion, but now it seems group-think is the way to go. You've convinced me! :confused: :eek:

h8kurdt 05.26.2020 11:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
Pure, unadulterated ignorance on full display here, folks. While Sonic Youth do have some political songs, they are far from being a political band. But please, GeneticKiss, continue to tell me what I'm allowed to like/dislike. I used to be all for diversity and inclusion, but now it seems group-think is the way to go. You've convinced me! :confused: :eek:


The irony of this coming from a Trump supporter.

You got a stupid man, you got a Ku Klux Klan

Screaming Skull 05.26.2020 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
You got a stupid man, you got a Ku Klux Klan


Funny you quote Youth Against Fascism, as Sonic Youth's most overtly political songs often end up being cringe inducing...see: Youth Against Fascism and Peace Attack.

!@#$%! 05.26.2020 02:27 PM

nothing more cringe-inducing than a maga chud

h8kurdt 05.26.2020 02:27 PM

Tbh, if you think Sonic Youth aren't political then you haven't been paying much attention. Like, at all.

Screaming Skull 05.26.2020 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
Tbh, if you think Sonic Youth aren't political then you haven't been paying much attention. Like, at all.


While members of SY have certainly expressed their personal political views over the years (Lee's interest in the Occupy movement years ago, Kim canvassing for Bernie most recently, etc), Sonic Youth has never been a political band - at least not in comparison to Dead Kennedys, Fugazi, Rage Against the Machine and the like. Can you name 10 overtly political Sonic Youth songs?

I'll give you the first two:

1. Youth Against Fascism
2. Peace Attack

h8kurdt 05.26.2020 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
While members of SY have certainly expressed their personal political views over the years (Lee's interest in the Occupy movement years ago, Kim canvassing for Bernie most recently, etc), Sonic Youth has never been a political band - at least not in comparison to Dead Kennedys, Fugazi, Rage Against the Machine and the like. Can you name 10 overtly political Sonic Youth songs?

I'll give you the first two:

1. Youth Against Fascism
2. Peace Attack


You're ignoring their interviews which they seemed to talk about politics in every one of them. Sure you'll screech that that doesn't make them a political band or something.

Edit:add to that the amount of benefit concerts they'd played over the years.

Bytor Peltor 05.26.2020 03:24 PM

May 15, 2020 (page 434)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bytor Peltor
What Judge Sullivan is attempting to do is unconditional!
(let that sink in)

Also, in our judicial system, a case or controversy is required to proceed. Judge Sullivan’s Court lacks jurisdiction —SIMPLE AS THAT— when the Executive Branch withdraws because there is no longer a case or controversy, IT’S OVER!!!


The Executive Branch dropping the charges ENDS IT!!!


Last but not least, the Department of Justice can get a Writ Of Mandamus from the federal appellate court in Washington DC to compel Judge Sullivan to do his job!!!



Desperation = a state of despair, typically one which results in rash or extreme behavior

Federal Judge Hires High-Powered D.C. Attorney To Defend His Actions In The Flynn Case

Why would a Federal Judge need to defend his actions in a case?
(let this sink in)

Is Judge Sullivan ignorant regarding his authority?

Is Judge Sullivan just playing politics??

To recap, Judge Sullivan appointed a retired Judge John Gleason to prosecute General Flynn because the Department Of Justice wanted to drop the charges. The DOJ was admitting there was no legitimate reason for their initial investigation.

It appears to me that Judge Sullivan got caught up trying to use his Civil Authority in a criminal case......but it can’t be this simple, can it?

So the Writ Of Mandamus is granted by the circuit court (appeals court) and it requires Judge Sullivan to explain his decision of appointing outside council. Also, Judge Sullivan must explain why as Judge of the case, he instructed the retired Judge John Gleason on how he should carry out his actions.

Now that Judge Sullivan has painted himself into a Judicial corner, and the circuit court is seeking answers......Judge Sullivan lawyers up???

A Federal Judge ”shouldn’t” need representation to respond to a Writ Of Mandamus......should he?

I’m guessing the conflicts are numerous! Also, obvious reasons why Judge Sullivan should have recused himself and didn't, therefore overstepping his authority in his handling of this case.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robert Schunk
My one point of agreement with Mr. Levin is that Judge Sullivan erred in appointing a strawman counsel to draught a brief opposing the motion, as it's properly the role of the judge himself with or without the assistance of his law clerks to consider causes for dismissing the motion.



Mr. Schunk, PLEASE help shed some light on this......by hiring an attorney, is Judge Sullivan now saying he is a party to the case?

Can a Judge be a party to the case and still preside over the case?

Granted, Judge Sullivan did bring in retired Judge John Gleason, but by doing so, did Judge Sullivan relinquish his authority over the case?

Lastly, and this is hard to imagine and I (doubt?) it’s legal......but Judge Sullivan can’t seek outside council regarding how he should rule??????

Screaming Skull 05.26.2020 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
You're ignoring their interviews which they seemed to talk about politics in every one of them. Sure you'll screech that that doesn't make them a political band or something.


Can you name 10 overtly political Sonic Youth songs?

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 11:13 AM

Alright, I'll bite. Only because I wanna see how you move the goalpost because you can't handle the idea that your viewpoints have absolutely nothing in line with what sonic youth as a collective ever preached.

Dude Ranch Nurse
Paper Cup Exit
Do you believe in rapture
Society is a hole
Teenage riot
Chapel Hill
Anti-orgasm
Rain on tin
Youth against facism
Peace attack

Don't forget protest-records.com, all the interviews (especially in their later years) they did where they talked about politics and their stance against Republicans, the benefit concerts they played, the gender politics they shouted from the beginning that Trump and his cronies abhor. They were never slogan chanters like gang of four, fugazi and whoever but the politics were always there. Now fuck off and go listen to skrewdriver instead.

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
Alright, I'll bite. Only because I wanna see how you move the goalpost because you can't handle the idea that your viewpoints have absolutely nothing in line with what sonic youth as a collective ever preached.

Dude Ranch Nurse
Paper Cup Exit
Do you believe in rapture
Society is a hole
Teenage riot
Chapel Hill
Anti-orgasm
Rain on tin
Youth against facism
Peace attack

Don't forget protest-records.com, all the interviews (especially in their later years) they did where they talked about politics and their stance against Republicans, the benefit concerts they played, the gender politics they shouted from the beginning that Trump and his cronies abhor. They were never slogan chanters like gang of four, fugazi and whoever but the politics were always there. Now fuck off and go listen to skrewdriver instead.


o·vert (/ōˈvərt,ˈōvərt/) - adjective - done or shown openly; plainly or readily apparent, not secret or hidden.

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 11:54 AM

Lol. Moron needs lyrics to be nice and clear so he can understand them. Like I say, skrewdriver might be a bit easier for you to understand. Go there.

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 11:56 AM

lolololol

must spread more buttah

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 12:06 PM

Anyway, in more Trump news. Twitter has finally decided to call him out on his constant lies and included a fact check warning on a post about mail voting. He's not liking this at all and saying it's impeding his free speech (it isn't) and threatening to close down Twitter (he can't).

Been overdue for Twitter to do it.

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 12:35 PM

orange tantrum baby missed his calling as the queen of hearts

 

GeneticKiss 05.27.2020 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
Pure, unadulterated ignorance on full display here, folks. While Sonic Youth do have some political songs, they are far from being a political band. But please, GeneticKiss, continue to tell me what I'm allowed to like/dislike. I used to be all for diversity and inclusion, but now it seems group-think is the way to go. You've convinced me! :confused: :eek:

Funny how you somehow think racism/homophobia/fascism/etc are just differing points of view when in reality, the people you've chosen to ally with would stamp out any point of view other than blind loyalty to the state and the inferiority of all ethnicities other than Caucasians.

GeneticKiss 05.27.2020 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
Alright, I'll bite. Only because I wanna see how you move the goalpost because you can't handle the idea that your viewpoints have absolutely nothing in line with what sonic youth as a collective ever preached.

Dude Ranch Nurse
Paper Cup Exit
Do you believe in rapture
Society is a hole
Teenage riot
Chapel Hill
Anti-orgasm
Rain on tin
Youth against facism
Peace attack

Don't forget protest-records.com, all the interviews (especially in their later years) they did where they talked about politics and their stance against Republicans, the benefit concerts they played, the gender politics they shouted from the beginning that Trump and his cronies abhor. They were never slogan chanters like gang of four, fugazi and whoever but the politics were always there. Now fuck off and go listen to skrewdriver instead.

I'm not sure "Youth Against Fascism" is the best example given as it's actually making fun of politically aware teenagers, albeit ones that do it for the wrong reasons.

"Kool Thing" is an attack on LL Cool J and other "sensitive" rappers who got all kinds of positive views from feminist publications while not actually doing anything for feminism; just not being misogynist.

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
Lol. Moron needs lyrics to be nice and clear so he can understand them. Like I say, skrewdriver might be a bit easier for you to understand. Go there.


We all hope
To signal kin
Days of gold
Now rain on tin
Gather round
Gather friends
Never fear
Never again


Not exactly 'God Save the Queen' or 'Holiday in Cambodia', but whatever.

While individual members have certainly expressed their political views, Sonic Youth - as a vehicle/weapon - is not a political band.

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 01:43 PM

It's about 9/11. Not sure what else to add to that.

And God save the Queen? Hahaha! If that's your standard for a political song then bless. You keep telling yourself they aren't.

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 01:59 PM

Written as Sonic Nurse was coming out...

"For a group who have existed mostly under right-wing regimes and whose caustic, experimental guitar sound has seen them labelled as one of the most influential bands of their time, Sonic Youth have largely avoided making political statements with their music."

...

"Sonic Nurse closes with the band's only significant protest song since Youth Against Fascism from 1992's Dirty album. Over six minutes long, Peace Attack was written by vocalist/guitarist, Moore, and its theme ensures Sonic Youth's stance is clear, says Ranaldo."

We'll never agree, so this is my last post on the subject. But - yes - I will continue to enjoy the music of Sonic Youth, even though you'd like to exercise control over the music as media (#EasternBloc).

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 02:17 PM

Reminds of that monty python quote

"All right... all right... but apart from better sanitation and medicine and education and irrigation and public health and roads and a freshwater system and baths and public order... what have the Romans done for us?"

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
Anyway, in more Trump news. Twitter has finally decided to call him out on his constant lies and included a fact check warning on a post about mail voting. He's not liking this at all and saying it's impeding his free speech (it isn't) and threatening to close down Twitter (he can't).

Been overdue for Twitter to do it.


Or - seen through a different lens - Twitter and the left want to shut down Trump's unfiltered access to potential voters on their platform. His message is deemed too dangerous unless filtered, distorted, and manipulated by the left-wing media. #EasternBloc

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
Or - seen through a different lens - Twitter and the left want to shut down Trump's unfiltered access to potential voters on their platform. His message is deemed too dangerous unless filtered, distorted, and manipulated by the left-wing media. #EasternBloc

lmfao

so it’s safe to inject yourself with bleach, pinocchio?

that asshole you worship spews so many dangerous lies it’s impossible to keep count

he’s the distorter and manipulator

MAKE LYING WRONG AGAIN

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
lmfao

so it’s safe to inject yourself with bleach, pinocchio?


The left only honors the First Amendment or #MeToo when it's in synch with their agenda.

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 02:41 PM

 

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 02:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
The left only defends the First Amendment or #MeToo when it's in synch with their agenda.


same could be said about your boy...

I'd have thought people would want the president to be accounted for his lies. Maybe not.

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
 


Oh, that's right - there was no lying or corruption in the Obama administration...none at all. :eek:

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
Oh, that's right - there was no lying or corruption in the Obama administration...none at all. :eek:

ah yes, because “not zero” is equivalent to “infinite” in your addled mind, huh?

good luck with your fried logic board, i’ll see you next time on “dolts on parade”

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
good luck with your fried logic board, i’ll see you next time on “dolts on parade”


I'll look forward to seeing you on Tuesday, November 3rd. Remember in the wee hours of Wednesday, November 9th 2016 when Hillary was in a heap and couldn't muster the courage/energy/composure to deliver a concession speech? Get used to that fetal position...it'll come in handy again, I promise.

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
I'll look forward to seeing you on Tuesday, November 3rd. Remember in the wee hours of Wednesday, November 9th 2016 when Hillary was in a heap and couldn't muster the courage/energy/composure to deliver a concession speech? Get used to that fetal position...it'll come in handy again, I promise.

lmfao if that’s a promise that you’ll fuck off for 5 or 6 months then kindly deliver already

 

demonrail666 05.27.2020 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by h8kurdt
Alright, I'll bite. Only because I wanna see how you move the goalpost because you can't handle the idea that your viewpoints have absolutely nothing in line with what sonic youth as a collective ever preached.

Dude Ranch Nurse
Paper Cup Exit
Do you believe in rapture
Society is a hole
Teenage riot
Chapel Hill
Anti-orgasm
Rain on tin
Youth against facism
Peace attack

Don't forget protest-records.com, all the interviews (especially in their later years) they did where they talked about politics and their stance against Republicans, the benefit concerts they played, the gender politics they shouted from the beginning that Trump and his cronies abhor. They were never slogan chanters like gang of four, fugazi and whoever but the politics were always there. Now fuck off and go listen to skrewdriver instead.


I do think Kim is an overtly political figure but I'd say the others largely fall into the same standard liberal category that applies to most 'creatives'. But it's always felt more meaningful for Kim, especially in relation to feminist politics, from early songs like Flower, her becoming a kind of figurehead for Riot Grrl, onto later songs like 'Swimsuit Issue', etc. A few songs aside, I would've never described SY as a political band in the 80s but I do think it became more of a focus from the 90s onwards, when Kim's profile and influence within the band started to increase.

As for whether it's an oxymoron for a SY fan to even contemplate voting for Trump, I'd say it depends what attracted them to the band in the 1st place. If they're more into stuff like 'Female Mechanic' then it probably is. Less so if they're more about stuff like DV69.

Screaming Skull 05.27.2020 05:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by demonrail666
I do think Kim is an overtly political figure but I'd say the others largely fall into the same standard liberal category that applies to most 'creatives'. But it's always felt more meaningful for Kim, especially in relation to feminist politics, from early songs like Flower, her becoming a kind of figurehead for Riot Grrl, onto later songs like 'Swimsuit Issue', etc. A few songs aside, I would've never described SY as a political band in the 80s but I do think it became more of a focus from the 90s onwards, when Kim's profile and influence within the band started to increase.

As for whether it's an oxymoron for a SY fan to even contemplate voting for Trump, I'd say it depends what attracted them to the band in the 1st place. If they're more into stuff like 'Female Mechanic' then it probably is. Less so if they're more about stuff like DV69.


See, a nice level-headed post devoid of words like 'moron', 'dolt', or 'chud'. SY's musical dynamics are what originally attracted me to the band in 1991. The music - combined with mysteriously poetic lyrics and themes - were/are an undeniable combination for me. Sonic Youth will always be my all-time favorite band. If I dismissed bands/art based on liberal leanings I wouldn't have ANYTHING to listen to. I like the punk aesthetic of deriving energy and inspiration from rebellion...fighting the machine...and/or rallying against "the man". However, in practice, I believe that capitalism and small government serve more people than socialism and big government. By no means is it perfect, but I don't know of a better model.

!@#$%! 05.27.2020 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
See, a nice level-headed post devoid of words like 'moron', 'dolt', or 'chud'.

ah, yes... if we only had a president who could tweet like that!

maga chuds will be maga chuds

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
ah, yes... if we only had a president who could tweet like that!

maga chuds will be maga chuds


Zing!

h8kurdt 05.27.2020 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Screaming Skull
See, a nice level-headed post devoid of words like 'moron', 'dolt', or 'chud'. SY's musical dynamics are what originally attracted me to the band in 1991. The music - combined with mysteriously poetic lyrics and themes - were/are an undeniable combination for me. Sonic Youth will always be my all-time favorite band. If I dismissed bands/art based on liberal leanings I wouldn't have ANYTHING to listen to. I like the punk aesthetic of deriving energy and inspiration from rebellion...fighting the machine...and/or rallying against "the man". However, in practice, I believe that capitalism and small government serve more people than socialism and big government. By no means is it perfect, but I don't know of a better model.


Everything that trump isn't?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:55 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth