Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Unpopular Musical Opinions (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=972)

MellySingsDoom 07.29.2009 05:22 PM

Oh alrght then, just for you:

Joe Strummer is thorougly over-rated as a guitarist, and The Clash are unmitigated wank.

(Am I doing it right now?)

Derek 07.29.2009 05:27 PM

Yes Melly! YES!

sarramkrop 07.29.2009 05:27 PM

yeah, the mc5 are crap.

automatic bzooty 07.29.2009 05:31 PM

clash hatin' is certainly unpopular with me. unless yr dissing sandinista, fuck that shit.

sarramkrop 07.29.2009 05:33 PM

i've seen mick jones walking down oxford st. on sunday night, and i wanted to stop him to tell him that the clash were shit, but he looked fatigued and tired. Maybe he was tired of being rubbish for so long.

demonrail666 07.29.2009 05:39 PM

Mick Jones always looked a bit fatigued and tired when he was in the clash too. the price you get for being in a shit band, i suppose. He looked far more sprightly in Big Audio Dynamite, what with his big baseball cap.

Satan 07.29.2009 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by automatic bzooty
clash hatin' is certainly unpopular with me. unless yr dissing sandinista, fuck that shit.

sandinista is fucking shit

rock the casbah is also a pile of wank

demonrail666 07.29.2009 05:43 PM

sandanista's alright really. i definitely prefer it over any other clash album. probably because large parts of it sound fuck all like the clash.

Satan 07.29.2009 05:45 PM

i love a good blasting of should i stay or should i go on the stereo once in awhile

combat rock is kind of shit though except without straight to hell we wouldn't have the fantastic "paper planes"

sarramkrop 07.29.2009 05:45 PM

Do you think that if he slept more regularly the clash would have turned out to be less shit?

automatic bzooty 07.29.2009 06:13 PM

i like combat rock. about half of it, anyway. straight to hell is their best song.

give em enough rope sucks, too.

edit: i was going to say that the clash would have been better off without mick jones but then i remembered cut the crap. haha.

demonrail666 07.29.2009 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Do you think that if he slept more regularly the clash would have turned out to be less shit?


good point

Satan 07.29.2009 07:37 PM

straight to hell is nowhere NEAR their best song
that is easily the most flippant statement i have ever heard in my life

demonrail666 07.29.2009 07:51 PM

magnificent seven is their best song. and even that's shit.

automatic bzooty 07.29.2009 09:20 PM

i knew i should've thrown in that "pretty much" somewhere.

well, if it's not straight to hell, it's guns of brixton.

Satan 07.29.2009 09:29 PM

i like them. i dunno. i think people expect too much of musicians.

Satan 07.29.2009 09:40 PM

i totally see where youre coming from. i agree for the most part. i prefer crass myself.

i think i like the undertones more than i like any punk band

Decayed Rhapsody 07.29.2009 10:14 PM

Only songs I've heard by The Clash in my entire life are: White Riot, Rock The Casbah, London Calling, Guns of Brixton. I always thought of them as an angry pop band.. not really punk.

I also agree about the punk and politics bit. Rarely does music that is political from the get-go turn out to be something worthwhile as MUSIC. This is why I still can't get behind Bikini Kill. Yet I really like Huggy Bear. Anyway, here is an example of shitty political music, a thoroughly uninspired commentary on white privilege: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S8popa7M4tI

SuperCreep 07.29.2009 10:17 PM

All the Clash-bashing makes me a saaaaaad panda. :7(

 

atsonicpark 07.29.2009 10:28 PM

11 emails in my myspace, what the fuck

Rob Instigator 07.29.2009 10:30 PM

not enough or too much?

atsonicpark 07.29.2009 10:40 PM

too much!

some chick sent me 3 emails with the same idea, but all variations on her sentences. "i want to rant to you about something..." *15 minutes later* "i really need to rant and rave about something but i don't know if you want to hear about it..." *2 hours later* "hey you may not care but when you get a chance, write me. i kinda want to rant about something."

Satan 07.29.2009 10:41 PM

.....wtf

chairman of the bored 07.29.2009 10:46 PM

well they said that we were crap,
the name of the bands crass, not clash

fugazifan 07.29.2009 11:52 PM

i still really like the clash
although i barely listen to them.
but the first album and london calling are amazing, and combat rock has some really good tracks...

demonrail666 07.30.2009 01:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Satan
i like them. i dunno. i think people expect too much of musicians.


but then again, you're a girl so that sort of negates any opinion you might have on this most manly of topics.

Fugazifan has said much the same thing but, as a male, his opinion obviously carries significantly more weight.

Death & the Maiden 07.30.2009 01:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by automatic bzooty
edit: i was going to say that the clash would have been better off without mick jones but then i remembered cut the crap. haha.

I think I prefer Mick Jones to Joe Strummer, mainly because I like his voice a lot more.
I like the UK version of their first album, a few songs from Give 'Em Enough Rope, most of London Calling is great, some of Sandanista is good, and then I don't really care for most of the rest.

loubarret 07.30.2009 03:20 AM

wavves has to be the most shitty pitchfork wankers band so far.

atsonicpark 07.30.2009 03:26 AM

Wavves are great. Awesome songs. Just catchy, simple, melodic poppy, noisey power chord rock. Nothing mindblowing but nothing offensive. There's a slow, surfy song on one of their albums that is easily one of the best songs I've heard in a long time. Nothing too original, but it's still great. Could use some better production though, the "hey, we recorded everything clean but then ran it through some shitty VST plugin effect so it sounds like garbage!" schtick kinda sucks. I love the poppy vocals. They're really good, I hope semi-popular music goes more in that direction rather than wherever the fuck it was going before. I don't totally understand the ENORMOUS hype, to be honest, because there's about a billion other great bands doing truely unique, wonderful things that no one gives a fuck about... so, yeah, I "get" the backlash.. but in all reality, they're still a great band.

As far as bands that have great, simple, poppy bands who have blown up overnight thanks to the internet, though, no band can top Vivian Girls. I LOVE them. Just amazing music.

Also, Pitchfork rules! Not as good as Drive Like Jehu or Hot Snakes but John and Rick had to start somewhere!!

loubarret 07.30.2009 03:30 AM

I like pitchfork but not those indiekids how live by it and take it as their bible.

Wavves just doesn't do it for me, I tried and tried but I just keep stuck that I'm Bored is a nice song but for the rest it's crap. And the guy is a total ass.

Satan 07.30.2009 03:31 AM

wavves are so fucking lo fi, i love it

loubarret 07.30.2009 03:33 AM

Everyone how is a bit into rockmusic is saying I should check them and I would love it. To be honest their/he is tottaly on my alley in musical taste but it sounds just like some big pile of overhyped crap to me.

atsonicpark 07.30.2009 03:38 AM

Yeah, it's overhyped. The songs are still cool, though. Personally, I am glad that there are still musicians out there, hyped to hell or not, who are just focusing on writing catchy, simple good songs. Obviously, he's not the only one who's doing it -- but compared to most of the shit that gets hyped up to Hell (who the fuck is this Grizzly Bear band everyone on my myspace is listening to? what is that bullshit? UGH), he's not bad at all.

OH -- but I gotta say, he does seem like a total fucking dipshit, in interviews and live. Of course, he's what.. 22? Hopefully he'll grow out of it...

loubarret 07.30.2009 03:43 AM

Or stop using drugs/alcahol. His drummer left the band throught his ego problems.

Grizzly Bear are a bunch of weak softhearted indierockers which everyone seems to fall in love with.

In these days I miss bands as be your own pet....

atsonicpark 07.30.2009 03:46 AM

I'd like to be aunt jemima pearl's pet.

loubarret 07.30.2009 03:47 AM

Tottaly.

Accutaly guys the new arctic monkeys is quit fucking good.

dionysusundone 07.30.2009 03:54 AM

Y'know I didn't 'get' Wavves for a long time, but they totally clicked for me recently. I think I was just turned off by everyone and their dad being into them

Satan 07.30.2009 03:56 AM

more awesome shit if you like wavves

http://www.myspace.com/crystalstilts
http://www.myspace.com/beachfossils

Rob Instigator 07.30.2009 09:12 AM

the shittiest pitchfork wanker band is goddamn FLEET FOXES

fucking HATE

mad HATE

john DENVER HATE


egverything on pitchfork these days is so fucking WEAK

Rob Instigator 07.30.2009 09:17 AM

Fuck The Weak Shit


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:52 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth