You are a lone on an uninhabited island....
 

***alone

i'd need someone to talk to, and seeing as its a female the bottom half would be useless to me. plus fish heads are scary!

I'm going to have to go with "A" as well.

the constant "fwap fwap" would drive me crazy....I'd end up frying her up one night. :(

srsly

I voted A. while a human 'gina would be delicious, I could not get off looking at that flapping gill face. gross.

ofcourse the regular. you can talk and teach her. and shed be a lot prettier than some legs attached to a fishs head

she can breath under water too, so can you imagine the great head you would get?

for porkie:

awesome

dya reckon mermaids smell all fishy?

not only that! in the likely event that you may have to kill, slice & grill her for sustenance, fish filets taste a lot better than fish heads. just saying...

i wonder what a blowjob from type b would be like though?

mmm very......different

that's easy to try if you're thinking about doing the experiment-- a nocturnal visit to your local aquarium should provide the opportunity-- i must warn you however to stay clear of moray eels.

I chose the bottom, why? don't ask, I think I have a fish fetish.

I chose the top one. Having someone to talk to and be a companion with is much more important than being able to fuck a human vagina.

Plus I could still tittyfuck her and she could still give blowjobs.

throat fucking is also possible.

atleast with the top half you could get a blowjob from an atractive face and not a fish. Plus, its hard to talk to a fish.

Obviously A. Who would fuck a fish head?!

A

Even though it doesn't have a vagina, I can have anal sex with it (which I'm surprised no one mentioned)

you just had to spoil it didnt you!

Version A hands down.

She could talk. She could smile. And she would have tits.

that does not look like what I was promised in the picture.

I demand a refund!

bottom; for the survival of the "human" race.
Hope to dont regret :)