The greatest musical city
 

In most peoples eyes it would come down to
New York
London
Manchester
Detriot
Austin TX

All are well documented, what other places have people to suggest? In particular cities on different continents.

in the US, not mentioned above

Los Angeles
Seattle
Memphis
San Francisco/Oakland
Chicago

Boston

jerusalem-you all just dont know it yet:-)
western mass has a lot of cool stuff hapening in it right now (most notably east and northhampton)

Montreal
Toronto
Vancouver
Chicago no-wave/noise/experimental/whatever
Chicago Albini
California (San Fransisco) experimental punk
Oakland
uh, etc.

here in mexico, guadalajara.

Minneapolis, jerks.

ohh yes, have you heard Movus? and of course there must be Descartes

Gotta lose your mind at Detroit Rock City.

Osaka as for Japan.

But what city is it???? I wanna go there.

I also wanna check out Erotic City

london's ok, but it's hardly in the same league as new york

leeds used to have a great diy scene but it became spoiled and cliquey and ruined. it does have a good improv scene but everyone lives in such close proximity its a bit annoying.

Bristol comes to mind, but that's largely based upon its past. I don't know whether or not there's much happening there now.

Oh, and Berlin. Shame on you, Jon Boy, for not mentioning Berlin.

EDIT - Also Cologne and Dusseldorf

to be honest there is not a huge amount going on there. there is an ok improv type scene but otherwise its not that great. the techno has moved from cologne to berlin though.

We can't just throw in every city that has a music scene as a contender for greatest musical city. Bristol? Leeds? Even Manchester is a bit of a stretch, considering how the legendary hacienda club was a load of my arse.

New York City, no doubt. More listenable careers have been born there than anywhere else.

Danny's right, New York hands down.

Montreal used to be pretty ace due to Constellation movement.

Liverpool should be in the list of also ran cities. But New York and maybe London (although NY would probably be the 'greatest' whatever the criteria)

A nod maybe, but most places are just one-scene towns. Historically maybe they are very important but New York City has given birth to many scenes; punk, hip hop, no wave, anti folk..

yeah, movus are awesome.

have you heard piscis? dragón? sutra? mekedo airono (zapopan, i know, but neighboring city)? inspired by the clouds? marlento?

descartes' album is amazing.

by the way, where have you been?

I wasn't kidding with Minneapolis.

Prince
Suicide Commandos
Replacements
Husker Du
Atmosphere
Brother Ali
Alexander East
Gay Beast
To Kill A Petty Bourgeoisie
The Trashmen
Morris Day & the Time
Jimmy Jam & Terry Lewis
Eyedea & Abilities
...

The list goes on. MPLS might not have the biggest scene, but per capita, i think we've got the greatest amount of great bands.

of all of those only Mekedo Airono and Sutra, i will check it out the other bands myspace's, also you know Movus is going to play here in the city with A Colores?

haha i had a computer crash and a lot of homework but, yes i'm back

might be going to university in leeds... what kind of places do they play all this improv shit?

US: NYC!
CAN: Montreal!
UK: London!

Philadelphia and Baltimore as of the past 15 or so years.