Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   JC (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=21175)

tasteinmen 04.13.2008 01:11 AM

JC
 
Anybody else think this song is amazing? It's got the highest amount of plays according to my itunes playcount. I just think it's beautiful. It sounds alot different to the rest of the songs that are on dirty in terms of style. One of Kims finest moments, a few levels below shadow of a doubt but that's just my opinion. what u think?

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 04.13.2008 02:32 AM

Great song. It's got that haunting quality to it that most post DDN songs don't have.

greenlight 04.13.2008 02:51 AM

great track. love it.

by the way, even though Kim vocaly did a great job on it, brought the right emotion to it, I like instrumental version from rehearsal recording more. JC is great, Moonface is excelent. I'm going listen to it now.

✌➬ 04.13.2008 03:00 AM

Yes one of kim's greatest song. However, for me it has to be Bull in the Heather.

tasteinmen 04.13.2008 07:27 AM

I'll have to give moonface a proper listen. and I agree about the haunting feeling, the intro reminds me of shaking hell because of the shrumming that sounds like chiming.

ZEROpumpkins 04.13.2008 07:30 AM

Yeah I really like this song, it's very underrated. Second best song on Dirty maybe.

Death & the Maiden 04.13.2008 07:59 AM

This is one of the only songs from Dirty that I can't recall from memory, I always get it confused with Chapel Hill. I think I thought it was a good song the last time I listened to Dirty.

sarramkrop 04.13.2008 08:06 AM

It's one of my favourite on this album too.

ZEROpumpkins 04.13.2008 08:06 AM

Chapel Hill is good too, but they are totally different songs man.

Death & the Maiden 04.13.2008 08:10 AM

I know they're different songs, I just can't help mixing them up because JC doesn't stay in my memory.

ZEROpumpkins 04.13.2008 08:23 AM

Ironically, It is a song IN memory of a roadie who was murdered.

Torn Curtain 04.13.2008 09:55 AM

For those who haven't seen it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrmCM1Zga0A

RanaldoNecro 04.13.2008 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Torn Curtain
For those who haven't seen it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrmCM1Zga0A


What about Jimmy Chamberlin? Jesus Christ?

I first heard 'JC' via the Alternative NRG compliation which now usually sells fro a .01.

seek it out..

Also has a great live version of REM's 'Drive'.

Pax Americana 04.13.2008 11:58 AM

Great song. Maybe my favorite on Dirty, actually. Yeah it's about Joe Cole. I believe that 100% is also about him, or at least part of it is. The part about being shot in the head... Cool live video, by the way. I wish they still played this live.

max 04.13.2008 12:33 PM

yes, 100% is about Joe Cole.

I remember listening to JC one evening coming out of a shower in the midst of a sunset (my home has a lot of windows and it was a wonderful sight), with the music tuning into something really intense and in that very moment something clicked inside of me: I cried a bit and all of a sudden I was one with the sounds out of the stereo.

A very precious memory for me.

RanaldoNecro 04.13.2008 11:28 PM

Its probably one of the most intense songs I've ever heard

Rob Instigator 04.14.2008 09:09 AM

JC is one of the best songs on Dirty. It fucking blows me away. i always forget about it but then it comes on and I fucking love it.

barnaclelapse 04.14.2008 10:49 AM

Love that song.

Good call.

el duderino 04.16.2008 06:48 PM

its definitely one of the most emotional songs they've done. I always admire how they get the guitars to sound so chaotic, yet structured in this track - teetering on thr edge!

Top 5 for me

Chris Lawrence 04.17.2008 12:46 AM

it's nice to see so much appreciation for this song! it's the type of song only they could write, the way those guitars, just.. sound, almost random but somehow combined create a really unique song. beautiful.

GrungeMonkey 04.17.2008 03:57 PM

absolutely beautiful song, the guitar textures are incredible, and kims delivery really fits the mood of the song

nature scene 04.17.2008 04:13 PM

it's one of those songs that sends a wave of chills up your spine everytime

This Is Not Here 04.17.2008 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nature scene
it's one of those songs that sends a wave of chills up your spine everytime


A couple of months ago shortly preceeding the start of a long spell apart due to my freinds' travelling, we decided to make eachother the compilation to end all compilations. Basically our all time favourite tracks. I thought long and hard about the SY tracks, I settled on three, Theresa's Sound World and Shadow of A Doubt and decided that JC had to be on there due to the sheer beauty of the peice, I always find it really moving when lyrics are really drowning in guitar noise like they are here (No More Sorry by MBV, same effect, same emotional response) and the lyrics are just so moving particularly if you know what they're about. We each wrote a paragraph on why we like the songs/ bands, heres a little of what I wrote about JC:

"JC, from the same album, is one of the Sonic’s most feedback laden tracks, its written about Joe Cole, a Black Flag roadie and the frontman Henry Rollin’s best friend, who was shot dead in a robbery at his home in ’91. It’s incredibly moving and always makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. Its certainly Kim's finest hour, probably the bands'. Music to die to."

RanaldoNecro 04.17.2008 09:40 PM

I used to work in an outdoor parking lot and listen to this on a cassette version of Dirty......I have distinct memories...

Was his murder not solved?

RN

Pessimist 04.18.2008 05:38 PM

Really good, yeah.

joe11121 03.29.2009 09:54 PM

JC is one of my favourite SY songs.

EVOLghost 03.29.2009 09:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe11121
JC is one of my favourite SY songs.


Indeed. Beautiful song.

fugazifan 03.29.2009 10:51 PM

this seems fitting. such a sad story.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vasIL6mtNIk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThZFJ...eature=related

hirsute_biped 04.01.2009 12:16 PM

JC and Theresa's Sound World = best songs on Dirty


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth