Favourite SY Album of the 90's
 

Okay this is a follow up to the 'Favourite SY Album of the 00's' thread (in which 'Sonic Nurse' was the clear winner). Its kinda pointless doing a thread about their 80's albums, because 'Daydream Nation will always get the most votes. The 90's however is a tricky decade and divides many opinions. Sonic Youth's output is probebly more polarized than it had ever been before or since in the 90's. In my experience people who like 'Goo' or 'Dirty' dont warm to the late 90's stuff like 'A Thousand Leaves' and vice-versa (not always the case with hardcore fans). So it will be interesting to see the board's favourite.

A Thousand Leaves
Washing Machine
Goo
EJSTNS
Dirty

I don't have SYR:4 so therefore it can't be ranked.

Goo

Washing Leaves with A Thousand Machines

can you make a multiple answer pole please ?

Lol as long as 'Experimental, Jet Set...' doesn't win

1. goo (very nostalgic album for me... "cindrella's big score" and "disappearer" are my all time favs)
2. washing machine (just one word here for me: "unwind")
3. a thousand leaves (it has a couple of songs which I really love, "hoarfrost" and "wildflower")
4. ejstns (I like it but its really "no star" album..)
5. syr4 (it's hard to compare this with others because of different style)
6. dirty (worst sy album ever imo)

ATL is a very close second for me... in fact so close it hurts... SYR4 just nudges ahead because I'll never forget the cold chill thrill that ran up and down my spine the first time that I heard it... and also it opened up a hole new musical universe for me...

Washing Machine or Goo, I went with Washing Machine.

Washing Machine is my favorite, with Goo a close seconde. Then I would say A Thousand Leaves and Dirty. Experimental Jet Set is okay, not great. As is SYR4.

My top three SY LP's include one from each decade, and the 80'd representativeis Dirty.


Even if that's the case, I think it would be interesting to see just how much of the vote it gets and where other votes go. Evol and Sister in particular seem to be very popular indeed on this forum.

Washing Machine is the one that makes me feel dizzy and stroke a stranger's head(to quote Lenin's idea of what music is) and 'A Thousand Leaves' is a close second.Here was a band at the height of their powers or anyone's powers at that.

Washing Machine + Goo

(Washing Machine, being the only SY album I'm yet to own, cannot be ranked)

Goo
ATL
Goodbye 20th Century
Dirty
EJSTANS (I love it, but I cannot place it higher... I do love it...)

EJSTANS is a much maligned album but i still love it and it pisses me off that it gets criticized so much when they have made worst albums than that(and so we're clear,i think that Sonic Youth have made a false move only with the last two).

EH LISSEN TO THIS RYTE me n me mates huffi n jiddi n jaffi 'the professer' yeh, once we did the experimentals y'kno, in the nayme of the psyentiffik resertch like, we got a stoopid fukkin gnome policeman who ad been lyke reely opressivs on the goblins n we hid 'im in a cave in the forest of light n then we made 'im lissen to all the sonical yuth rekkords rite, n it was DEFFINITTLY THE WON THOWSAND LEEVS that pissd 'im offs the mowst, so i say that won yeh eh.

Washing Machine.

Nurse has got one of the most morbid Youth lyrics in 'I Love You Golden Blue',though.