The Red Album was one of the worst albums ever -- ASIDE FROM "greatest man who ever lived", which is 6 minutes long and completely changes style 18 times or something. It's the weirdest Weezer song ever -- it almost sounds like them trying to do Mr. Bungle or something?! I highly reccomend listening to it, it's very ambitious, even though some of the lyrics are cringeworthy.
Weezer are just perfectly fine power pop. Nothing more, nothing less. Anyone can play these songs. Just boring power chords. I'd rather see a petition to end NOFX or something, because at least they (or Fat Mike) go out of their way to shove their politics down people's throats. Weezer are harmless, and the guitarist was in Carnival Art:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCCdZtrvf50
Watch this video!