http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/sho...5&postcount=61
Most likely Daycare Nation's ex-roommate's tale is an exaggerated one. Let us assume that items were, in fact, borrowed. Usually an account such as his has some grain of truth to it, & I'll refrain from a blanket assertion that it is a complete fabrication. Sonic Youth probably re-strung the guitars with very heavy guages & tuned them exceedingly tight as they are wont to do & damaged the tuning pegs, hairline fissured the neck at the base or busted a bridge or something during their performance. It is readily known that they are rough on instruments & the like. I can never imagine that they actually "destroyed" loaned equipment & maintain that any hypothetical damage that ensued was certainly not deliberately or maliciously intentional.
That's my take & you can take it to the bank.
Things like this routinely get blown out of proportion & embellished for effect by all parties involved because people are bored & it makes for a better story in their warped minds that have little to no respect for the truth of things.
I figured that after four pages of second guessing & jibber-jabber, sixty-six replies & close to six hundred views, that someone might appreciate a sensible response, so I posted.
Again, that's the most likely explanation. I'm not attempting to protectively, as a fan, offer up plausible deniability for Sonic Youth's sake, because this event, as described (sickeningly & repeatedly),
never happened. Hearsay doesn't hold water in a court of law & it doesn't fare well under scrutiny on a Sonic Youth message board either given the nature of the charge.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Daycare Nation
My question was, would it bother anyone if it were true?
No one seems to be answering that--they seem more concerned with discovering who my friend's band is.
|
Daycare Nation keeps going back to this question & it's a rather moot point because Sonic Youth fans should not be put on the spot & forced to answer a question like this when the alleged incident is based solely on hearsay. And of course people want to know which band his ex-roommate is in to gain more information to possibly further this debate, because their curiousity has been piqued, & also to test his credibility, naturally. It seems both surprising & odd that Daycare Nation would not realize this himself & that he would be such a tireless advocate for his ex-roommate's yarn. At any rate, his diatribe has been resoundingly blown to smithereens & an airtight case for reasonable doubt has been made by myself.