[demonrail666]

Well I'm not even sure what qualifies as 'Noise', but anyway:

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre:
2. A Noise band that defines the genre:
3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island:
4. One Noise song that makes you smile:
5. One Noise song that makes you frown:
6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are:
7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are:
8. Japanese or American:
9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers):

[pokkeherrie]

4. merzbox

(duh, saw that one coming, did you?)

Originally Posted by demonrail666

Well I'm not even sure what qualifies as 'Noise', but anyway:


4. One Noise song that makes you smile:

4. The Gerogerigegege - Dick Echo

One of the best names for a song ever. And this guy is a bottomless well of good song titles.

[Trasher02]

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre: Anything by Merzbow probably
2. A Noise band that defines the genre: The Haters
3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island: Wolf Eyes - Human Animal
4. One Noise song that makes you smile: Wolf Eyes - Dead in a Boat
5. One Heavy Metal song that makes you frown: lol
6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are: SWANS
7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are: Xiu Xiu
8. Japanese or American: Japanese
9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers): Scooter + Jinx

[demonrail666]

1 and 4: Spit n Shit - Pussy Galore
2: Pussy Galore
3: Soul Crusher - White Zombie
5: Crimes Against Skin - Eyehategod
6: The Thrown Ups
7: ?
8: America
9: Ghost Bitch

[gualbert]

3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island:I certainly don't want any noise album on a desert island ( I don't even want one on a crowded continent ).
4. One Noise song that makes you smile: CCCC made me smile , live . They played one 30 minutes song but I don't know the name of it.

[atari 2600]

1. A Noise Song (in this case also an album) that defines the genre:
Lou Reed "Metal Machine Music"

2. A Noise band that defines the genre:
I don't know, maybe Whitehouse.

3.Two Noise albums you would want on a desert island:
Robert Fripp and Brian Eno, Evening Star
Glenn Branca, Symphony No. 1

4. Two Noise songs that make you smile:
Fripp & Eno - "An Index of Metals"
Henri Chopin - "Dynamisme Integral"

5. One Noise song that makes you frown:
most of them

6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are:
I'm sure there's an obvious good answer that I'm not thinking of, but don't want to rack my brain over this right now.

7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are:
Sonic Youth...although they have some "noise" releases too, they are far too often thought of as strictly "noise." Take the mention in Juno, for instance.

8. Japanese or American:
American

9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers):
"Mieux: de Corrosion"

[Everyneurotic]

ohhh man, now things are going to get ugly!!!! i can already feel the air of superiority of the boardies ready to say "this poll is shit, noise is shit!!!! everyone who listens to noise is shit!"

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre:

unoriginal but it hits the spot: merzbow - rainbow electronics

2. A Noise band that defines the genre:

yellow swans

3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island:

kevin drumm - sheeer hellish miasma

4. One Noise song that makes you smile:

rubbish - untitled track 4 (if memory serves me correct) of vexanation, the great american outhouse.

5. One Noise song that makes you frown:

in disgust? all of wolf eyes - river slaughter; lazy piece of crap.

6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are:

so many: pita, atari teenage riot, early anal cunt, etc.

7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are:

wolf eyes, melt banana, boredoms, dinosaur jr, sebadoh, yellow swans*, jesus lizard, anything mike patton related, etc.

8. Japanese or American:

the lazy answer is worldwide but of these two, japanese; i would go with british as they pioneered and influenced the japanese who perfected it and made it unto it's own. nowadays, the british scene is the most versatile with ashtray navigations, blood stereo, vibracathedral, bbblood, towering breaker and affiliated artists and groups making a huge variety of sounds.

9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers):

lazy answer: silver sessions; other answer: mote or anything in syr4.


*yes, yellow swans can define noise but at the same time not be thought up as noise, both instances for the reason of them being so versatile and not wanting to stay in one place and even exploring sounds and styles unrelated to noise (like ambient, electronica and rock, this last one in small corners) that other purists might frown upon, yet it's this willingness to explore that defines a crucial aspect of the noise that most people involve take for granted or don't even consider, that is, the desire to experiment.

[Rob Instigator]

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre: There are none for the genre is undefinable.
2. A Noise band that defines the genre: They are interchangeable, so this does not matter
3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island: none, the sounds of nature are the only "noise" I would need on an island
4. One Noise song that makes you smile: none
5. One Noise song that makes you frown: most everything I have heard and it seems that this is the sole purpose of any "noise" act.
6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are: don't know
7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are: don't know
8. Japanese or American: who cares? noise is noise.
9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers): second half of MOTE.

[Dead-Air]

Well I'm not even sure what qualifies as 'Noise', but anyway:

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre:"Gran Concerto Futuristico" by Luigi Russolo

2. A Noise band that defines the genre: Bastard Noise

3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island: Metal Machine Music by Lou Reed

4. One Noise song that makes you smile: "Scooter & Jinx" by Sonic Youth (especially if the video is on!)

5. One Noise song that makes you frown: "Might!" by Boyd Rice

6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are: early Einsturzende Neubauten

7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are: Actually, my own band Dead Air Fresheners gets reviewed as "noise" fairly frequently, which is really pretty ridiculous as we're as often very quiet as noisy.

8. Japanese or American: I kind of like the whole Japanese Noise cliche, but when I look at the bands and artists I really like they're much more often American.

9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers): "Silver Shirt"

[SpectralJulianIsNotDead]

Does Cage count as noise? 4'33" makes me smile.

[gualbert]

Did you buy the CD? ( or vinyl , or mp3...)

[HaydenAsche]

1. Song? Ha.
2. Unfortunately, somebody like Wolf Eyes I'm sure.
3. Yellow Swans - Bring the Neon War Home
4. Hair Police - Do you like hop hop?
5. Anything that's generic static.
6. I don't know. I think that noise is a shitty label.
7. Discussed below
8. They're both great and terrible at times. Japanese is more thoroughly good.
9. Scooter & Jinx

I think that bands like Xiu Xiu and the like are more 'noise' than bands like Sonic Youth. I don't really know why but I feel like the whole electronic music thing fits more into the 'noise' genre than Sonic Youth's static and feedback.

[HaydenAsche]

Originally Posted by Everyneurotic

6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are:

so many: pita, atari teenage riot, early anal cunt, etc.

ATR were one that I was going to say.

I agree with the Yellow Swans thing. They're so much more noise to me than Wolf Eyes or any of that shit.

[gmku]

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre: Don't know.
2. A Noise band that defines the genre: Don't know.
3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island: Suggest something.
4. One Noise song that makes you smile: Can't think of one.
5. One Noise song that makes you frown: Can't think of one.
6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are: I have no idea.
7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are: I have no idea.
8. Japanese or American: I have no clue.
9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers): Beats the hell out of me.

 

 

 

[PAULYBEE2656]

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre:
2. A Noise band that defines the genre:
3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island:
4. One Noise song that makes you smile:
5. One Noise song that makes you frown:
6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are:
7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are:
8. Japanese or American:
9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers):

answer to all is merzbow

[_slavo_]

1. A Noise Song that defines the genre: anything off 1930 by Merzbow
2. A Noise band that defines the genre: Hijokaidan, Incapacitants
3. One Noise album you would want on a desert island: Francisco Lopez - Untitled #89
4. One Noise song that makes you smile:
5. One Noise song that makes you frown:
6. A band that should be thought of as Noise, but rarely are: Swans were a good call
7. A band that shouldn't be thought of as Noise, but regularly are: Yellow Swans
8. Japanese or American: japanese hands down
9. Sonic Youth's most Noise song (no covers): the ending part of Mildred Pierce

[Everyneurotic]

interestingly enough, no one mentioned any power electronics.