[demonrail666]

Who of all the famous dead rockstars do you think would've made the greatest contribution to music had they not died when they did?

I was going to do a poll but I'm sure I would've missed someone key. So ...

[LifeDistortion]

Hard to point out one but I'd probobly go with Bob Marley

 

Reggae music has been put into every other kind of genre of modern music in some capacity since his death, be it rock or hip-hop, or some other style.

[Sonic Youth 37]

He made his mark and was gone. I may be wrong, but reggae is reggae is reggae, not much diversity in sound (cue flaming by Suchfriends (and possibly others) in 3....2...1....)

[demonrail666]

Thinking about those that are still alive, Clapton, Macca, Page, Townsend, Jagger, Richards, Dylan, etc, none of them have really contributed much past the seventies, making me think it's unlikely that any of those that died so relatively early in their careers would've done that much of any interest. I'm not sure point I'm trying to make here, if any. Maybe that the death of someone like Lennon or even Hendrix was obviously a tragedy for him and those around him, but probably no great loss to music after that point.

That's obviously not taking into account post-60s figures like Ian Curtis, Stevie Ray Vaughn, Kurt Cobain, Dimebag Darrell, etc.

[Sonic Youth 37]

Buddy Holly?

[SuperCreep]

Coltrane, Hendrix, Curtis, D Boon, Sam Cooke, Jhonn Balance, Elliott Smith...basically a bunch of people that died when they were still producing great music and probably had a shit ton more worthwhile releases to give to the world.

[Shifty Prophet]

Thing about Hendrix is that by all accounts (his included) he was really getting burned-out with his career. He wasn't happy with the majority of the records he put out and was hoping to go into another direction. of course, when you listen to his final recordings you can obviously tell he wasnt at the same place he was at for axis or electric ladyland. This new direction that he was heading, while perhaps in the end would have been cool, at the time and now, doesn't sound that good.

[Dead-Air]

Originally Posted by Shifty Prophet

Thing about Hendrix is that by all accounts (his included) he was really getting burned-out with his career. He wasn't happy with the majority of the records he put out and was hoping to go into another direction. of course, when you listen to his final recordings you can obviously tell he wasnt at the same place he was at for axis or electric ladyland. This new direction that he was heading, while perhaps in the end would have been cool, at the time and now, doesn't sound that good.

Really? "Machine Gun" on Band of Gypsies is a totally awesome foray into heaviness in my book. Hendrix had set some rather high standards for himself to top, but given the time to do it, he might have invented whole new genres of music.

[Decayed Rhapsody]

Hendrix going into a more free jazz direction/hooking up with Miles Davis would have been amazing. Worst case scenario would be if he turned into Santana or something.

Not a rockstar, but I really think Albert Ayler could have reached even greater heights.

[RanaldoNecro]

michael jackson

[viewtiful_alan]

Biggie

[LifeDistortion]

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37

He made his mark and was gone. reggae is reggae is reggae,

Bob Marley introduced regaee to America and that music like I said has influence both the rock genre and the hip-hop genre. Nobody can't deny that Bob Marley's music influenced bands like The Clash, and pretty much any other politically minded artist like Public Enemy. You say reagee is regaee is reggae. So many artists have taken elements of reggae music and incorporated them in rock and hip hop music. And have Bob Marley to thank for introducing them to that type of music. Certainly he's not the only one who was making that kind of music at the time but you can't deny that he introduced it to the wider world.

[demonrail666]

Originally Posted by LifeDistortion

Bob Marley introduced regaee to America and that music like I said has influence both the rock genre and the hip-hop genre. Nobody can't deny that Bob Marley's music influenced bands like The Clash, and pretty much any other politically minded artist like Public Enemy. You say reagee is regaee is reggae. So many artists have taken elements of reggae music and incorporated them in rock and hip hop music. And have Bob Marley to thank for introducing them to that type of music. Certainly he's not the only one who was making that kind of music at the time but you can't deny that he introduced it to the wider world.

I'd agree with his impact and influence but I'm not sure if he'd have made any great contribution in later years. He'd have more likely been the same kind of figurehead that he is now, only a living rather than dead one.

[Satan]

 

[deflinus]

 

[Rob Instigator]

is steve perry dead?

ha ha ha!

[Rob Instigator]

My answers

 

 

[Satan]

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

is steve perry dead?

ha ha ha!

if only....

[Zombie Robot]

Cobain
Hendrix
Cash
Coltrane
Stayley
Lennon
Presley
Mercury
Joplin
Easy E
Curtis
Harrison
Boone
Carptenter
Crash
Nico
Sargent

soooo many

Kurt Cobain
There were hints that Nico could have turned good again before she died, who knows?