[matt g]

sonic youth - 8/10
confusion is sex/kill yr idols - 6/10
bad moon rising - 6/10
evol - 9/10
sister - 10/10
daydream nation - 10/10
goo - 7/10
dirty - 7/10
ejst&ns - 6/10
washing machine - 5/10
a thousand leaves - 8/10
nycg&f - 7/10
murray street - 9/10
sonic nurse - 8/10
rather ripped - 7/10

syr1 - 7/10
syr2 - 6/10
syr3 - 6/10
syr4 - 5/10
syr5 - 8/10
syr6 - 5/10
syr7 - 6/10
syr8 - 7/10

tv shit - 4/10
made in usa - 6/10
whitey album - 8/10
suburbia - 8/10
silver sessions - 6/10
hidros 3 - 5/10
in the fishtank - 5/10
the destroyed room - 7/10

[xxlouiisxx]

sonic youth - 9/10
confusion is sex/kill yr idols - 10/10
bad moon rising - 9/10
evol - 9,5/10
sister - 9,5/10
daydream nation - 10/10
goo - 9/10
dirty - 9/10
ejst&ns - 9/10
washing machine - 9/10
a thousand leaves - 9/10
nycg&f - 9/10
murray street - 9/10
sonic nurse - 9/10
rather ripped - 9/10

I'm being kind but I've just never heard a band better than SY

[Rob Instigator]

my ratings

sonic youth 8/10 (I do not like Satan Is Boring)
confusion is sex 9/10
bad moon rising 9/10
evol 10/10
sister 10/10
daydream nation 100/10
goo 9/10
dirty 9/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 1/10
washing machine 8/10
a thousand leaves 9/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 7/10
murray street 7/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 8/10

the whitey album 8/10


sonic youth is my all time fave band!!!!!

[Derek]

Originally Posted by mil_pl

experimental jet set, trash and no star 2/10

that is radical step Derek!

I hate that album.

[Rob Instigator]

me tooooo

[mil_pl]

Originally Posted by Cantankerous

rather ripped 0/10

why is that ? you hate all songs ?

[SonicBebs]

Sister 8/10
Daydream Nation 4/10
Goo 4/10
Dirty 7/10
EJSTANS 4/10
Washing Machine 9/10
A Thousand Leaves 9/10
NYC Ghosts and FLowers 9/10
Murray Street 10/10
Nurse 9/10
Rather Rippd 7/10

SYR1 7
SYR2 7
SYR3 8
SYR5 3
SYR6 8
SYR8 7

dont have the others

[jetengine]

Sonic Youth 6.5/10
Confusion Is Sex 9/10
Kill Yr. Idols 6.5/10
Sonic Death 6.5/10
Bad Moon Rising 7/10
Death Valley '69 7/10
Walls Have Ears 7.5/10
EVOL 7/10
Sister 9/10
Master=Dik 5.5/10
Daydream Nation 10/10
Candle 6/10
Ciccone Youth: The Whitey Album 7.5/10
4 Tunna Brix 6/10
Goo 7.5/10
Dirty Boots Live 7/10
The Goo Demos 6.5/10
Venlo/Live '83 5.5/10
Dirty 7.5/10
Whore's Moaning 7/10
T.V. Shit 5/10
Experimental Jet Set, Trash, and No Star 6/10
Blastic Scene 6.5/10
Live in Bremen 6.5/10
Washing Machine 9/10
SYR1 6.5/10
SYR2 7/10
SKR1: The Silver Sessions 7.5/10
A Thousand Leaves 9.5/10
SYR3 7.5/10
SYR4 8/10
NYC Ghosts & Flowers 7/10
Murray St. 7/10
In The Fishtank 6/10
Hidros 3 7/10
Sonic Nurse 8/10
SYR5 7/10
Rather Ripped 8/10
The Destroyed Room 7/10
SYR6 (Haven't heard it yet)
SYR7 (Haven't heard it yet)

The Reissues:

Dirty Deluxe 8.5/10
Goo Deluxe 7/10 (Three LPs spread out over 8 sides with many of the b-sides and live tracks left off--I think many of us were unsatisfied with this repackaging.)
Sonic Youth Deluxe 7.5/10
Daydream Nation Deluxe 8/10 (Again, they should have included all the b-sides and more demos, instead of live tracks which have been bootlegged a dozen times over.)


Did I forget anything?

[mil_pl]

bootleg is not an album. we are rating only official realeses. but it's ok, you've done your homework with surplus!

[Derek]

those bootlegs are official bootlegs though

Originally Posted by SonicBebs

Sister 8/10
Daydream Nation 4/10
Goo 4/10
Dirty 7/10
EJSTANS 4/10
Washing Machine 9/10
A Thousand Leaves 9/10
NYC Ghosts and FLowers 9/10
Murray Street 10/10
Nurse 9/10
Rather Rippd 7/10

SYR1 7
SYR2 7
SYR3 8
SYR5 3
SYR6 8
SYR8 7

dont have the others

cheers another murray lover...but the DDN diss....BUT you love murray street

[SonicBebs]

Originally Posted by jetengine

Did I forget anything?

can't believe you left off Hold That Tiger. Call yourself a Fan...?

[SonicBebs]

Originally Posted by al shabbray

cheers another murray lover...but the DDN diss....BUT you love murray street

ha! Never liked DDN. too clumpchy sounding.

but yeah, Murray Street! Woo!

[SonicBebs]

that didn't mean to sound as sarcastic as that

[SYRFox]

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

my ratings

sonic youth 8/10 (I do not like Satan Is Boring)

wait... what?

[SYRFox]

I'd go like this

Sonic Youth -> 8/10
Confusion Is Sex -> 10/10
Bad Moon Rising -> 15000/10
Evol -> 9/10
Sister -> 9/10
Daydream Nation -> 9/10
Goo -> 6.5/10
Dirty -> 7/10
Experimental Jet Set, Trash And No Star -> 8/10
Washing Machine -> 8/10
A Thousand Leaves -> 8/10
NYC Ghosts & Flowers -> 10/10
Murray Street -> 7/10
Sonic Nurse -> 9/10
Rather Ripped -> 7/10

Sonic Death -> 9/10
Made In USA -> 7/10
The Whitey Album -> 8.274/10.000 (it's weird so I give it a weird rating)
The Destroyed Room -> 7.5/10

SYR1: 8/10
SYR2: 7.5/10
SYR3: 9.5/10
SYR4: 8.5/10
SYR5: 8/10
SYR6: 9/10
SYR7: 7.5/10
SYR8: not listened yet

TV Shit: EEIGGGGGGHHHHHHHT OUT OF TEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN
Silver Sessions: 9/10

That's right. I gave everything a good rate. So what? I can't be objective with them, I love everything they've done and that's it

[acousticrock87]

Sonic Youth - 6/10
Confusion is Sex(/Kill Yr Idols) - 8/10
Bad Moon Rising - 7/10
Evol - 6/10
Sister - 7/10
Daydream Nation - 9/10
Goo - 5/10
Dirty - 9/10
Experimental Jet Set - 10/10 (yep)
Washing Machine - 5/10
A Thousand Leaves - 9/10
NYC - 10/10
Murray Street - 9/10
Sonic Nurse - 5/10 (though I've probably listened to it less than any others, so I'm not sure)
Rather Ripped - 6/10

Others (I don't own very many):

Sonic Death - 8/10
Whitey Album - 6/10
SYR 6 - 6/10
Lundeberg EP - 9/10
Destroyed Room - 10/10
DDN Deluxe - 9/10
Psychic Hearts - 7/10
Trees Outside the Academy - 5/10

The three tens (EJS, NYC, and Destroyed Room) are hands-down my favorite, with ATL, Dirty, and Murray very close.

[Rob Instigator]

Originally Posted by SYRFox

wait... what?

satan is boring bores me.

[SYRFox]

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

satan is boring bores me.

yeah sure... but it's on bad moon rising

[SuperCreep]

Errr...isn't Satan Is Boring on the reissue of BMR?