[joe11121]

Originally Posted by Alex's Trip

It'd be funny if Kim Gordon played with Corgan.

hahaha yes it would

[uhler]

he doesn't want a female guitarist because he's scared a girl will play better than his shitty guitar playing self.

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by GeneticKiss

Female bass players are hot...

very

[ZEROpumpkins]

Actually, Billy is a pretty good guitar player, I'll give him that.

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by ZEROpumpkins

Actually, Billy is a pretty good guitar player, I'll give him that.

yeah lots of earlier pumpkins work, gish and siamese dream material, some mellon collie is good playing too. but then he kind of got lazy. he can still play the old songs well. like at concerts. but some of his songs are very simple. kind of seems like he rushed the writing process just to get more cash. sooner. he's alright at guitar playing, but nothing special.

[Sonic Youth 37]

I hate the reworked version of BWBW for the C tuning. I always have. James was just as good, if not better than Billy

[jennthebenn]

He's not kidding. Cubs fans are ridiculously into their pathetic fucking team
of unparalleled shithead losers, able to rant at length about the overall
suckitude of all the players and coaches while not being able to hold a half
decent conversation on any subject of actual importance.

All the smart ones jumped to the White Sox bandwagon.

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37

James was just as good, if not better than Billy

I liked james. he was a skilled player, i didn't like his voice though.

[ZEROpumpkins]

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37

I hate the reworked version of BWBW for the C tuning. I always have. James was just as good, if not better than Billy

That's another thing they're doing wrong, metal tunings.

[Sonic Youth 37]

I love it for Everlasting Gaze though...and whatever tuning Real Love is in...might be the same one.

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by ZEROpumpkins

That's another thing they're doing wrong, metal tunings.

He [Billy] said that he was taking his pumpkins into a new direction. and trying to get away from the past, some of the new songs are pretty good, but i dont understand why he feels the need to run away from the pumpkins musical history, like is he trying to forget james and d'arcy? that's another thing, they hate billy so much now. like what could he have done to them which made them hold a grudge for almost 10 years now. it's pretty crazy. they should stop the fighting, james and d'arcy should rejoin and maybe they would talk some musical sense into billy.

[ZEROpumpkins]

Haha, exactly. I wonder what they think of new pumpkins.

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by ZEROpumpkins

Haha, exactly. I wonder what they think of new pumpkins.

haha, they're probably thinking, how the hell did that happen. haha. but like i said some of the new tracks aren't that bad like american gothic is a pretty good ep. 99 floors, peace + love, and a song for a son are all good tracks. there are a few others too.

lots of people like the new song as rome burns, but seriously it is AWFUL!! seriously it is.

[GeneticKiss]

Originally Posted by joe11121

like is he trying to forget james and d'arcy? that's another thing, they hate billy so much now. like what could he have done to them which made them hold a grudge for almost 10 years now.

Overdub all their tracks on Siamese Dream, only allow James one song on Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, never allow James to take a real solo, basically treat them like image puppets, etc.

[pbradley]

This thread sucks.

[RdTv]

It does suck. Mainly because there is an actual,intentional, taking of sides. And it doesn't stop there, I witnessed glimpses of championing each aforementioned side.

When will people figure out that Corgan and Vedder are really just the same person going through different stages in life. Having really only one decent stage to each of their credit. The only thing worse than the SCI,WP,GD esque following of Pearl Jam, is the ramblings of a Smashing Pumpkins fan that keeps up with the groups current output.

[acousticrock87]

I would like to humbly take the side of noting that both Corgan and Vedder are quite human, and we're all douchebags in our own way.

Some bald guy talked trash. Who the fuck cares?

[hat and bread]

Let's make a useless thread useful and change it to the official "Chicago Cubs Suck" thread.

 

[ZEROpumpkins]

Originally Posted by GeneticKiss

Overdub all their tracks on Siamese Dream, only allow James one song on Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, never allow James to take a real solo, basically treat them like image puppets, etc.

Haha, how much would it sucks if he actually did that?
...wait

[✌➬]

Are people still talking about them? Vedder's music never did anything to me. He was too pop. Corgan's early stuff is better. remember when he released Gish on a floppy disc?