[krastian]

I love it like my grandma.

[Ripchord]

Originally Posted by Hip Priest

Sugar Kane: I sometimes wonder if two or three SY songs would have worked better as instrumentals. THis is one of them. It's still very fine though.

That's funny because Sugar Kane is one of my favorite songs on Dirty.

[Kyohan]

Patchy to say the least. The "Goo" commercial experiment taken too far...but there are great moments on there.

[Asim]

Worst SY album.

[LittlePuppetBoy]

I like it.

[Cantankerous]

dirty was a filler album, right along with goo, jetset, and washing machine.

[greenlight]

i like it.
esspecialy "rehersal" disc.

[the ikara cult]

as one who is 21 now and hence has no experience of the time Dirty was released (thank fuck), i love it. On the strip, Theresas sound world, Wish Fulfilment, 100%, Sugar Kane, Chapel hill... why its all lovely stuff.

[Washing Machine]

It's certainly not their greatest work. But it is an excellent album. I think it goes to show the huge range of the band. How many bands can create something like 'Dirty' and then make an album like 'NYCG&F'? In many ways its the perfect SY songform album.

[fluxequalsrad]

Originally Posted by Cantankerous

Butch Vig is now my least favorite person on the planet. He has produced three of the worst albums of all time (Dirty, Jetset, Nevermind). And he's in that awful band Garbage.

Butch Vig, you are now on my "dead to me" list.

you know nothing of production. (regardless...nevermind is brutal)

[atari 2600]

First of all, I love the album just like I love all the Sonic Youth albums.
That being said...
Strangely enough, Genetic & Hendrix Necro are probably better than any song on the album yet were not included on the original release.
I'd rather hear Kim sing Personality Crisis than David Johansen any day of the week. The same goes for Alice Cooper's Is It My Body?

Cantankerous, would you care to comment on just how a "filler album" has such great outtakes?

quick comments & impressions...

100% has cool lyrics & an edgy vocal delivery from Thurston, but the song is a bit grating really except for the outro.

Swimsuit Issue would be much better without the "mean-o" rhyming with "Encino". That's pretty lame.

Theresa's Sound-World hearkens back lyric-wise to Death Valley '69 & Shadow of a Doubt. When I first got diRty, it was a favorite, but not so much anymore.

Drunken Butterfly is much better as a live song than a studio track, but overall, it's too what I'll term "meathead crunchy" for me to laud much praise on it.

Shoot is a brilliant song from start to finish & has one of Sonic Youth's most memorable (if not the most memorable) basslines.

Sugar Kane is pretty damn dopey.

My Wish Fulfillment would be to swap this song for Genetic.

Hendrix Necro should have been on the album's original release instead of Orange Rolls, Angel's Spit.

Youth Against Fascism is indeed the bomb.

Personally, I've always liked the Nic Fit cover a lot.

The outro to On the Strip is virtually never discussed on this forum & it's pretty hot stuff.

Chapel Hill displays probably the most technical guitar work of any Sonic Youth song.

JC is so gorgeous it takes one's breath away.

Purr is a marvelously original love song.

Creme Brulee is a nice counterpoint & way to end the album. The song dynamics are pretty happening & the lyrical images are really good.

[trance feeeedback]

Originally Posted by Asim

Worst SY album.

I agree, not only is dirty my most hated SY album, it also one of my most hated albums by any artist.

[atari 2600]

Originally Posted by trance feeeedback

I agree, not only is dirty my most hated SY album, it also one of my most hated albums by any artist.

Well, isn't that special?

Yours is a statement of complete hipster absurdity.

So, you mean to say that Conway Twitty & say, Jim Nabors put out some better material?

...how about Kix or Warrant?

I'll remind you (yet again) that you stated that,
"it (is) also one of my most hated albums by any artist."

C'mon bro, snap out of the trance & give me some feeeedback.

[Protectmeyou]

great album with a couple of duds.

but worth it for "Theresa's soundworld" alone

[schizophrenicroom]

one of my favorite sy albums.

100% is the best opener- that mad feedback. thurston sounds rad cool, and steve rocks the drum solo. but steve always rocks. i can't really remember if they did this.. back then, i guess, but like with the recent gigs i've listened to, i hate how it is live.

the "encino/mean-o" is kinda cheesy, but otherwise i really love swimsuit issue.

the wish fulfillment demo is almost as good as the album. genetic could easily go in its place, but eh.

songs 11-15 are perfect. it's mostly the flow from on the strip right into chapel hill.

apart from washing machine (my arena is rather genius) dirty has the best b-sides.

[Cantankerous]

Originally Posted by atari 2600

First of all, I love the album just like I love all the Sonic Youth albums.
That being said...
Strangely enough, Genetic & Hendrix Necro are probably better than any song on the album yet were not included on the original release.
I'd rather hear Kim sing Personality Crisis than David Johansen any day of the week. The same goes for Alice Cooper's Is It My Body?
Cantankerous, would you care to comment on just how a "filler album" has such great outtakes?

The outtakes should have been the ones on the album. I love Hendrix Necro as if it was my own child.

[trance feeeedback]

Originally Posted by atari 2600

Well, isn't that special?

Yours is a statement of complete hipster absurdity.

So, you mean to say that Conway Twitty & say, Jim Nabors put out some better material?

...how about Kix or Warrant?

I'll remind you (yet again) that you stated that,
"it (is) also one of my most hated albums by any artist."

C'mon bro, snap out of the trance & give me some feeeedback.

well I didn't mean that, I should have said it is one of my most hated albums by any artist that I listen to. Hell, I know it is a million time better than stuff by those people you listed or other crappy albums. It's just for some reason I hate it, I just don't know why.

[Savage Clone]

"Youth Against Fascism" is easily as annoying to me as "Cherry Pie." More so, as I hold SY in high regard and expect Warrant to be crap.

[Neongod]

I like it. Here's my breakdown

The Good:
100% - the epitome of a good album opener: it sets the tone of the rest of the album
Thersa's Soundworld - Amazing guitar lines and an earthquake of a breakdown. Probably my favorite.
Drunken Butterfly - I put it here only after seeing it live...a true Kim rocker
Sugar Kane - It's so damn catchy yet above the "annoying" threshold
Youth Against Facism - The lyrics are great...especially the Clarence Thomas reference. The Bush lyric (the president sucks) coincidentially and unintentionally rings true today
Chapel Hill - Fun fun fun
JC - Dark, brooding, and moving...one of my favorite Kim songs
Purr - Another great rocker

The Fair:
Swimsuit Issue - too abrasive for me...not very impressive
Shoot - s'alright...just nothing special
Wish Fulfillment - the chorus just doesn't feel right
On The Strip - see Shoot

The Poor:
Orange Rolls, Angels Spit - I always skip or exclude this one. It just isn't pleasant to my ears
Nic Fit - Why?

The "I have no fucking idea how to rank this":
Créme Brûlèe - Weird and strange, no musical relevance, but effective as an album closer meaning a complete contrast from the opener but follows from the mood of the rest of the album

I also agree that the B-sides like Genetic and Hendrix Necro would have been great on this album, but at least we have the re-release and CD-burners.

[satirejohn]

Dirty is one of my least favourite SY albums. There are some good tracks but the album is just not good enough all the way through to live op to the standard of SY, and even the best tracks are not as good as the highlights of other albums. It's a good album though and Shoot is a hella kickass song!