[Severian]

P.S. Here’s your Jake Lockley

 

[Severian]

Ok, so “The Leftovers” (the novel by Tom Perotta) is, like, what I imagine a rough draft of the amazing, captivating, too-good-to-believe “The Leftovers” HBO show from, like, a fucking pitch meeting.

It’s not a bad book. It’s really not. But after watching the show, there’s nothing that thin little jaunt through surface-level post-Rapture existential crises can offer you. (Not that it’s about the Rapture, but that’s the easiest way to describe the Sudden Departure that occurs in both book and show.)

It’s like... imagine watching the THREE movies based on “The Hobbit” and expecting some big goddamn epic in the book, when the book is LITERALLY just kids stuff compared to what Tolkien had cooking.

I don’t know if I’d be mad at the show for going SO MUCH FURTHER in EVERY way if I’d read the book first, but ... as things stand, I am disappointed in the book.

What’s next.

[Severian]

Handmaid’s Tale the show is also better than Handmaid’s Tale the book.

That’s right! Fuck You, sophomore year college Lit class! TV did it better!

[!@#$%!]

Originally Posted by Severian

Handmaid’s Tale the show is also better than Handmaid’s Tale the book.

That’s right! Fuck You, sophomore year college Lit class! TV did it better!

it’s funny how “literature” is becoming obsolete somewhat

the (actual) death of the author is the rise of the showrunner-—and the rise of the writer’s room

i am old enough to remember when tv was SHIT hahahahaaaaa

[Severian]

Originally Posted by !@#$%!

it’s funny how “literature” is becoming obsolete somewhat

the (actual) death of the author is the rise of the showrunner-—and the rise of the writer’s room

i am old enough to remember when tv was SHIT hahahahaaaaa

Me too. TV used to suck. Even — no, especially — the “high dramas”.

Way I see it, Sopranos changed the game, and LOST expanded the horizons for what was possible in terms of engagement with audiences and balancing between genres. LOST was Star Trek for the post-911 PTSD case, and it amped everything up, specifically production values and the scale of narratives.

It was imperfect, but it helped launch the world we live in now, where Soprano-home HBO apparently recruits LOST creators to find meh books and construct narratives out of their skeletons that probably make the author go, “Oh fuck, why is my book so simple and boring?”

(And obvioisly West Wing, Oz and especially The Wire played a huge part, but I’m pointing to Sopranos and LOST as the causal agent for TV betterment.)

Best thing on TV used to be that half hour where Seinfeld busted up Must See (because it’s impossible to avoid and still watch Seinfeld) TV. And Simpsons sometimes. King of the Hill... what have you.

[!@#$%!]

you really missed out on buffy/angel

timing is everything i guess

[tw2113]

Started Frankenstein tonight

[Dr. Eugene Felikson]

Buffy and Angel still duke it out for my favorite show of all time.

Originally Posted by tw2113

Started Frankenstein tonight

Is this the one where Frankenstein's monster is a detective?

[Dr. Eugene Felikson]

Also, literature is anything but obsolete afaic. I'm falling in love with the written word in a way I haven't known in nearly a decade. Thank you, and your exemplary prose, Mr. Rothfuss

[guest]

just finished sombrero fallout for like the 4th time...



starting a confederacy of dunces, masterful that

[tw2113]

Originally Posted by Dr. Eugene Felikson

Is this the one where Frankenstein's monster is a detective?

Whatever the actual original is. No spin-off/derivative version. Just in case, this is the "reading" thread :P

[!@#$%!]

Originally Posted by Dr. Eugene Felikson

Buffy and Angel still duke it out for my favorite show of all time.

after years of prodding sev finally started watching but could not get past the old timey 4:3 aspect ratio and 90s flavor of it lol

which is very unfortunate... and he missed out.

[Severian]

Originally Posted by Dr. Eugene Felikson

Also, literature is anything but obsolete afaic. I'm falling in love with the written word in a way I haven't known in nearly a decade. Thank you, and your exemplary prose, Mr. Rothfuss

I still love literature. Just the film/TV adaptation-athon has gunned up the works a bit.

Used to be you could almost guarantee a book would be better than any film that might come of it. Now, things are different.

I blame Harry Potter!

No, seriously, anyone who’s watched “The Leftovers” and read “The Leftovers” surely can agree with me on this.

And “Handmaid’s Tale” feels downright barren (no pun intended) compared to what’s been made of it on the show, which is a much more effective portrait of the impending rise of religious authoritarianism.

[!@#$%!]

Originally Posted by Dr. Eugene Felikson

Also, literature is anything but obsolete afaic. I'm falling in love with the written word in a way I haven't known in nearly a decade. Thank you, and your exemplary prose, Mr. Rothfuss

not obsolete but... in decline, so to speak

writing used to be the last bastion of intelligence in a world of mass media

but not no more

or i should say-- TV is also "literature" now (the fancy kind)

been rewatching breaking bad now, and laughing so hard

either i've become stupider or tv has become really good

wishful thinking sez tv is wayyyyyyyy better than it once was

(but likely i have cognitive decline)

also consider that human resources that once would have flocked the novel, the theatre, etc (yes, theatron, fuck you, lol) are now going elsewhere

[Dr. Eugene Felikson]

Ah. Sounds like my theory about since movies are now being released online, and shot digitally, that they're essentially no different than high budget YouTube videos

[Dr. Eugene Felikson]

Originally Posted by tw2113

Whatever the actual original is. No spin-off/derivative version. Just in case, this is the "reading" thread :P

LMFAO, all this TV talk got me confused.

There's some (upcoming?) CBS show where Frankenstein's monster is a detective.

Of course you're reading the OG Mary Shelley novel though... not that Frankenstein Mobster comic book that I read once...

 

Don't mind me... I'll just be...

 

[pony]

is anyone on goodreads??

[choc e-Claire]

Originally Posted by pony

is anyone on goodreads??

I have an account from years ago, but I never do anything with it.

[Severian]

Originally Posted by pony

is anyone on goodreads??

I was, but stopped on account of the pressures associated with publicly announcing when I start a book. I fuckin’ hate that shit.

My whole life is deadlines. I don’t need them imposed on me — in actuality or just perceptually, in my head — by social goddamn media.

But maybe I’ll try it out again. What can I say, I’m a wild one.

[!@#$%!]

Originally Posted by Severian

I was, but stopped on account of the pressures associated with publicly announcing when I start a book. I fuckin’ hate that shit.

My whole life is deadlines. I don’t need them imposed on me — in actuality or just perceptually, in my head — by social goddamn media.

But maybe I’ll try it out again. What can I say, I’m a wild one.

people who kill their social media report increased happiness

DO IT

KILL KILL KILL

DO IT

MHUAHAHAHAHAHAAAA