[Tokolosh]

None.
I have a life, and it doesn't solely revolve around the creative lives of others.
As a matter of fact, I sometimes go a week or two without listening to music.
Much needed silence.

[crprte.idnty]

i'd consider myself a fan. i don't have an encyclopedia like knowledge of music. i also hate making recommendations to others.

[Toilet & Bowels]

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

I think anyone who says stuff like this is 12 years old and does not realize the meaning of the word EXPERT

It does NOT mean you know everything.

It does NOT mean you have a comprehensive knowledge bridging all musical genres and fields.

It does mean that you have a lot of knowledge, more so than the average person, about a specific field/genre/band/instrument.etc.

a person can be an EXPERT on toilet tissue and know nothing about bidets.

I can be an expert on sonic youth and know nothing about the Swans.

if you're so intent on calling yourself a music expert then fine, but i think there's a difference between being knowledgeable and being an expert.
anyway, what i was talking about as far as experts go would be someone like dj rick who from what i've seen here knows more about regional punk scenes than than the people who listen to that music and live in those places. people like him are experts, some people just listened to polvo when they were at college, and other people fall somewhere in between.

[Derek]

Originally Posted by Tokolosh

None.
I have a life, and it doesn't solely revolve around the creative lives of others.
As a matter of fact, I sometimes go a week or two without listening to music.
Much needed silence.

I could NEVER do that.

[Glice]

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels

if you're so intent on calling yourself a music expert then fine, but i think there's a difference between being knowledgeable and being an expert.
anyway, what i was talking about as far as experts go would be someone like dj rick who from what i've seen here knows more about regional punk scenes than than the people who listen to that music and live in those places. people like him are experts, some people just listened to polvo when they were at college, and other people fall somewhere in between.

I quite admire people like DJ Rick, who seem to have an entirely comprehensive appreciation for things. And I'll agree with your general criticism of Rob (mainly because it amuses me).

I was going to write earlier (that is, when I was sober) that my understanding of expert is that they're entirely capable of describing music in terms of music theory. As I've probably said earlier in this thread, the ability to dissect music in purely musical terms generally leads people away from enjoying it. I know some people who can extrapolate to an entire scene based on one or two songs of one band, and emulate quickly and easily. I'd say these people are experts. They're also the people who listen to least music.

Listen well, not lots...

[Savage Clone]

The more you learn about music, the more you realize just how much of Nothing you really know about music.

[Glice]

Originally Posted by Savage Clone

The more you learn about music, the more you realize just how much of Nothing you really know about music.

But you get better at pithy non-sequiturs about it.

[Savage Clone]

Originally Posted by Glice

But you get better at pithy non-sequiturs about it.

SONIC LIFE!!

[Glice]

Yeah!!!!!!!!

[Rob Instigator]

no one can know everything. anyone that knopws a good deal about a specific thing can be called an expert on that information. That's just how it works man~! you learn what you learn you know?