Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Shooting at Virginia Tech campus (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=12275)

jico. 04.17.2007 08:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
B. Some, but this keeping in mind that you are just taking away ONE tool from already violent hands.


a very powerfull one.

demonrail666 04.17.2007 08:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
guns being legal....people can hunt for their own food if they choose


What's wrong with the humble fishing rod?

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jico.
a very powerfull one.

Not the most powerful.

Florya 04.17.2007 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pookie[COLOR=red
Less people die.[/color]


At the risk of sounding pedantic, banning guns will not stop people from dying. Everyone dies.
Banning guns would allow more people to live for longer, and would cut down the need for so many prisons.

I wonder how much 'money/taxes' those killed by guns could have contributed to the American economy had they lived. Do you think it would be more or less than the amount of 'money/taxes' raised through the sale of guns. I'm pretty sure that it would be considerably more. So it makes economic sense to bring in gun control as well.

I'm not going to comment on this any more - you all know my thoughts on the subject and you can either agree or disagree as you see fit.

I hope that something changes before the next massacre, but I don't hold out much hope.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
w'ere concerned about safety.

lets ban cars

lets ban knives

lets ban drugs

lets ban alcohooooool

lets ban airplanes (how many died as a result of 9/11? valujet?

lets ban ART (its caused people to do some pretty fucked up shit)

lets ban sex (them stds are a killer)

lets ban cigarettes

gosh damn the world would be so fuckin' boring.


^ now that's a fucking idiot post...

Florya 04.17.2007 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
there is a form of gun control.

you gotta register in order to own one.

however, like heroine, you can get it regardless.

i dont actually live in the country (im pretty close to atlanta), but i am from the south, and i know and have lived in "country" environments.

shit, ive lived all over the us. washington state, florida, georgia, ive spent alot of time in new mexico (never "lived" there, but did stay on a navajo indian reservation for a brief period of time, been back to visit several time since) i lived in okinawa japan for three years.

im not some small minded cluessless hick that wears a jon deer cap and works on a farm. if that were the case, honestly here, most likely i wouldnt be on a sonic youth message board (ill admit though, ive met some pretty back woods mother fuckers who were pretty serious about some punk rock...heheh....look up "pier six brawlers" on myspace...reallllly trasht southern outlaw punk. ...i hate those dudes by the way, know em personally)

i think i have a very valid stance on guns.


I apologise if I gave the impression that I thought you were a 'hick'. That was never my intention.

jon boy 04.17.2007 08:06 AM

my thoughts are the same as floyra's.

sway just wants to argue for the sake of it i think.

Pookie 04.17.2007 08:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
guns being legal....people can hunt for their own food if they choose, they can defned themselves if need be.

the advantage of banning them...weaker folks being taken advantage of. just imagine how many more alpha male assholes would break into houses/rape/steal if it wasnt for the fear of possibly being shot


The most important post in this thread!

This post inadvertantly summarises the whole issue perfectly.

There is a genuine belief in large parts of America, that what stops criminal activity is the threat of death (hence the seemingly baffling refusal to abolish the death penalty), and it's exactly that attitude which means that gun culture will continue to exist.

The reason most people don't commit crimes (alpha male or not) has more to do with morality than the threat of punishment.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Not the most powerful.


true.

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:15 AM

Anyway, i'm terrified of guns and i wouldn't want to have one. But to just come up with ' another reason to ban guns' sort of statements whenever this sort of thing happens is plain laziness and and kills off what could be an interesting discussion, rather than making it flourish. I'm 100% sure that guns won't be banned after what happened, as sad as yesterday's happenings are. The society we live in is a capitalist one, therefore things like this happen and will happen again and gain. Either accept that, or else you are believing a lie, the lie that tells you that your opinion or mine count that much when it comes to decision-making.

jon boy 04.17.2007 08:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Anyway, i'm terrified of guns and i wouldn't want to have one. But to just come up with ' another reason to ban guns' sort of statements whenever this sort of thing happens is plain laziness and and kills off what could be an interesting discussion, rather than making it flourish. I'm 100% sure that guns won't be banned after what happened, as sad as yesterday's happenings are. The society we live in is a capitalist one, therefore things like this happen and will happen again and gain. Either accept that, or else you are believing a lie, the lie that tells you that your opinion or mine count that much when it comes to decision-making.


so what is a good reason to say another reason to ban guns?

demonrail666 04.17.2007 08:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
I'm 100% sure that guns won't be banned after what happened, as sad as yesterday's happenings are.


On that point we agree.

RdTv 04.17.2007 08:20 AM

Guns will never be banned in America, at least not in the forseeable future. You're talking about a country who's bread and butter are violence and exploitation. Banning guns in the US would be like banning beer in Belgium.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
how?

its true.

we're talking about a massacre... preventing them... that's what were talking about.

sure cigarettes alcohol and all that can kill... ever used on a massacre?
we cant ban airplanes, cars etc... we need them...


do you need guns? what for?

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jon boy
so what is a good reason to say another reason to ban guns?

Elaborating why you think that they should be banned, rather than just stating that you agree with this of that. Discussions are also good at elucidating things that, perhaps, one wasn't too sure about.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:27 AM

they sell war guns to the common citizen... for what the fuck do they need a war gun?

jico. 04.17.2007 08:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
how many people died from smoking related cancers last year...car accidents?


now that.."jico"...is a massacre.


massacre is a mass murder not mass dead.

jon boy 04.17.2007 08:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Elaborating why you think that they should be banned, rather than just stating that you agree with this of that. Discussions are also good at elucidating things that, perhaps, one wasn't too sure about.


yes see your point but it is a catalyst i suppose.

anyway i have explained my point of view on this now so i will let other people have their say.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:31 AM

i dont even know what gun this fuckhead used... let's say it was a handgun. imagine how many he could have killed with one t of these war guns they sell in his hands...

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
he just likes agreeing and dissagreeing, he doesnt like arguing.

;)

Swa(y), you're just being provocative now.

ZEROpumpkins 04.17.2007 08:32 AM

jesus this is like the largest growing thread on this board.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
what if the dude set off a bomb in the gymnasium..haha...wanna talk about a massacre...wanna talk about a blllllooooody fucking mess?????


that's why bombs are banned.

demonrail666 04.17.2007 08:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
theres no "stopping it".


Making rape illegal hasn't stopped it from happening, but does that mean we should just give up and legalise it? It's all about improving problems, not necessarily solving them.

Tokolosh 04.17.2007 08:38 AM

Please don't let this turn into the "Fight against Terror" crap!

sonicl 04.17.2007 08:39 AM

If this thread ever looks like it's going to go somewhere, could someone let me know. Thanks.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
bombs being banned didnt stop timothy mcveigh....and they sure as fuck didnt stop ted kaczynski.

now what are we to do?

you can make guns, as well as bombs...and niether are too difficult.

see man..the issue isnt banning it.



they didnt stop... but it sure helped...

lol... you'll never stop things like this from happening!... the point is how can you help reduce the number of times that things like this happen...

tesla69 04.17.2007 08:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)

lsd was made illegal...what good did that do?


none whatsoever.

demonrail666 04.17.2007 08:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
demon...yr smarter than that.


Don't be so sure. :D

sonicl 04.17.2007 08:45 AM

So killings of a number of people are acceptable, so long as it doesn't happen too often?

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)


see man..the issue isnt banning it.




A more serious issue is the blatant culture of violence (look at many a movie etc for proof) that is certainly highly visible in the output of the States when it comes to entertainment. Not saying that it happens only in the States, but it's certainly a much more widespread practice to portray violence in a glamorous way in the States, more than anywhere else. Take a movie like the Fight Club: stylish and all that, but it certainly doesn't say anything more than being violent and negative is the only way someone can prove themselves.


A disclaimer:

I'm not saying there that one has to be a pacifist either. If it comes down to defending yourself phisically, the only option would remain a violent one.

jico. 04.17.2007 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
reduce....fucking reduce????????


what a fucking joke.


this is happened how many times here in the us (at this scale)????

do you even know?

not many, thats for damned sure. (if yr talking "massaacre" still)

i saw list with number of times that that shit happened there.

are you happy with numbers? ok then.
have fun.

--/--

school massacre is an incident of violence at a school involving at least one actual death.

sonicl 04.17.2007 08:48 AM

I don't think that the USA has a greater tendency towards making films with violence in them than other nations, just a greater tendency towatds making films full stop. The "World Cinema" section of your local DVD store has plenty of violent films, possibly proportionately more than the rest of the store.

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:50 AM

That's like, 600 countries combined into the same section against a giant movie industry run by one single country.

sonicl 04.17.2007 08:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
That's like, 600 countries combined into the same section against a giant movie industry run by one single country.

Yes, that's what I said. The violence portrayed in the Hollywood movie industry just looks greater because there are more films from there being shown. I don't recall "La Haine" being shown at my local multiplex.

sonicl 04.17.2007 08:56 AM

Lack of respect for the value of human life seems to be pretty commonplace. Fourteen year old kids stabbing thirteen year olds, people killing a pensioner for the sake of stealing a pitiful amount of cash. The pertinent question would seem to be, how can people be taught to respect the value of another life?


EDIT - I think I've just echoed Nefeli there, haven't I?

atari 2600 04.17.2007 08:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the ikara cult
Thats what i said, it was premeditated, they would find a way of doing it if you banned guns.
I dont think its a "misperception" that guns are easier at all, i think the example i gave illustrates this; Its a proximity thing. Its easier for people to shoot someone dead than beat them to death with a bat or stab them to death. The example i gave showed that "normal" people were less capable of behaviour that endangered the life of others (again i hasten to add im not focusing on the obedience aspect of it) when it involved an act of physical aggression - Guns require less aggression therefore its easier for "normal" people to use them to kill.


I agree, the ikara cult. All your posts in this thread are very sensible.

And during a domestic dispute, as early reports allege this shooting sprang from, having a gun on hand increases the likelihood of someone getting seriously injured or killed. It seems in this case, the male student killed a female friend and then resigned himself to die after that, insanely motivated to take others with him.

Many here should be familiar with the statistics that if you own a handgun that you are likely to shoot someone you know in a dispute or have your own self killed by it.

sarramkrop 04.17.2007 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
I don't think that the USA has a greater tendency towards making films with violence in them than other nations, just a greater tendency towatds making films full stop. The "World Cinema" section of your local DVD store has plenty of violent films, possibly proportionately more than the rest of the store.


How many movies do you watch in a year?

floatingslowly 04.17.2007 09:01 AM

I think after watching the news last night, I've capitulated a bit.

although I still maintain that I do not believe that it will actually stop violence, I would not be opposed to extremely strict regulations on gun ownership.

like I said, I never planned on owning a gun so this really wouldn't effect me in any way that I can sense. although I feel like I would be giving up my convictions due to media attention, this horrific shit has to stop.

or we could just say fuck all and turn Los Angeles into a penal colony. surely the threat of going to LA would be enough to stop most of this.

sonicl 04.17.2007 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
How many movies do you watch in a year?

Not a huge amount, partly because I tend to avoid violent films.

Tokolosh 04.17.2007 09:04 AM

Imagine the massacre, if Bollywood started making gun crazy musicals.
 

Word!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:16 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth