[flophousefloozie]

Well, I didn't see a thread yet, so I'd like to say I think they're fantastic. I'm moving to Toronto, too.

"Constructive criticism"... ?

[davenotdead]

they are pretty great... the album is repetitive but so damn good.

[flophousefloozie]

Repetitive? Really?

[davenotdead]

the beats. i didnt notice it so much... but then friends would comment about it when i show it to them , and they are kinda right...

[flophousefloozie]

I suppose. I'm easily amused when it comes to "beats".

There are so many sounds overlapping, that if the beats became anything more complex, I think it might destroy the entire sound. In that sense, I think it's necessary to simplify that component...

[atsonicpark]

A bit too two-dimensional for my tastes but a song here or there is nice to listen to. There's just no depth to the music to make me want to listen to it constantly.

[SYRFox]

Hmm I don't know. I hear about them all the time from people that has similar tastes as me, they're friends with HEALTH, but then I listen and I can't find anything I like... maybe I didn't try enough

[ZEROpumpkins]

Did you guys hear about Crystal Castles ripping off some other 8bit band?
And yes, I'm serious.

[PAULYBEE2656]

the alice practice single is fucking amazing as too is their demo/session tracks single as well. but the album is so so. the 2 great eps are the first half of the album then it just goes all wrong. on first listen i was like... yeah, great, fucking great.... oh no, noooo .nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo...


shame because i like em but sorry, if you are a one trick pony, you better be able to do that trick standing on your head........

at least they are way better than hot shit... i mean chip.

[flophousefloozie]

Just one little bump. Just one.

[Cantankerous]

fucking love them

[super_charger]

I'm from Toronto and they weren't even on my radar until they exploded, but I liked what I've heard so far.

[fugazifan]

i might be moving to toronto in a few years

[SYRFox]

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

the alice practice single is fucking amazing as too is their demo/session tracks single as well. but the album is so so. the 2 great eps are the first half of the album then it just goes all wrong. on first listen i was like... yeah, great, fucking great.... oh no, noooo .nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo...


shame because i like em but sorry, if you are a one trick pony, you better be able to do that trick standing on your head........

at least they are way better than hot shit... i mean chip.

Hot Chip rules. They're really fun, and even their ballad songs that can seem annoying actually are interesting - at least live, 'cause if they didn't play them when I saw them two months ago, I'd probably have died of a heart attack, because the 5 first songs were hyper energetic.
But I don't really see what's the point comparing CC and Hot Chip, they have almost nothing in common except that they play electropop (okay sometimes Hot Chip use retro sounds as well but that's not really the same thing)

[PAULYBEE2656]

hot chip are probably one of the worst bands ive ever had the mispleasure in seeing.. i really think they are overrated and yeah, they dont have much in common with crystal castles except for the trendyness scenester electro clash/ indie crossover thing..........

this is a PERSONAL opinoin on hot chip, nothing more nothing less.. the first album was palatable to a point, the second one was god awful...... live they are terrible, live they are dull boring and just like watching a kids trying to be adults..... sorry, the other way around.... madness for a technopop generation....

also i wasnt comparing then to cc, i was just merely making a comment but now you brought it up........

[Derek]

I think they are awful tbh.

Just something for the NME to latch onto, no real substance in their songs, sounds like a gameboy dying etc.

[Pessimist]

Originally Posted by Derek

I think they are awful tbh.

Just something for the NME to latch onto, no real substance in their songs, sounds like a gameboy dying etc.

Agreed.

And someone mentioned earlier that Hot Chip was just a thing for hipsters to latch onto.

WE ARE TALKING ABOUT FUCKING CRYSTAL CASTLES, FOR CHRIST'S SAKE!

[atari 2600]

Settle down there, Pessimist. It was PAULY that originally turned many of us on to them. And besides, I'm mostly in agreement with his abbreviated critique.

[PAULYBEE2656]

OK, JEEZ... I MUST BE SPEAKING A DIFFERENT ENGLISH TO MANY...

I GOT THEIR DEMO SINGLE.. I LIKED IT, CRYSTAL CASTLES WE ARE TALKING ABOUT........
i then got their excellent alice, practice e.p. the one with the blackened eye madonna photo (which is now banned with original artwork) and loved it, amazing shit. i was excited about this band... i then got their remix album which was pretty ok for a remix album and then i got their new album which is the first 2 singles (i have already mentioned their quality in the above couple of sentences) and 8 other tracks of pretty repetitive drivel.........

so crystal castles were great, the album is a let down after the 2 e.p.s tracks have finished... nothing new and for god sake, anyone who doesnt see the scenester thing and media hype surrounding these is blind!

as for my hot chip jibe, THATS ALL IT WAS, A COMMENT ON A PISS POOR ELECTROCLASH BAND THAT HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH CC APART FROM THE FACT THEY ARE TRENDY AND USE COMPUTERS...


so maybe next time you plan to jump down someones neck, how about doing some fucking research first or at least reading the fucking posts......


sorry guys but for christ sake as the pessimist put it!!!! read people read......dont assume!

[Pessimist]

Originally Posted by atari 2600

Settle down there, Pessimist. It was PAULY that originally turned many of us on to them. And besides, I'm mostly in agreement with his abbreviated critique.

Hell.

I don't like either band at all, but they are both WELL within the province of hipster-shiek, so I think it a bit unfair to say (in a negative fashion) that either band is celebrated by hipsters.